Top Insurance Companies in Coshocton, Ohio

Finding the right insurance company is key to getting the coverage you need at a price you can afford. Coshocton, Ohio is home to various national and regional insurance carriers offering policies for home, auto, business, health, life and more. This article will discuss the top insurance companies available to Coshocton residents and businesses.

How We Chose Coshocton’s Top Insurance Companies

To come up with this list, we looked at several factors:

  • Number of policies in force locally
  • Range of insurance products offered
  • Financial strength ratings
  • Customer satisfaction ratings
  • Availability of discounts and special programs
  • Local agent support and availability

The goal was to highlight well-rated insurers with a strong presence in the Coshocton market across key insurance sectors.

Top Insurance Carriers in Coshocton

State Farm

The largest auto and home insurer in the U.S., State Farm has served Coshocton for over 90 years. They offer policies for auto, homeowners, renters, condo, flood, life, health, business and more.

State Farm has an A++ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best. J.D. Power ranks them above average for auto and homeowner satisfaction.

With local State Farm agents and support, they make the claims process smooth with 24/7 assistance. State Farm offers many discounts like multi-policy, safe driver, and good student.


Headquartered in Columbus, Nationwide has a strong presence across Ohio. They provide insurance products for home, auto, farm, life, business, and pets.

Nationwide has an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best. They rank above average on J.D. Power’s U.S. Auto and Homeowner studies.

Serving Coshocton for over 90 years, Nationwide has local agents to help customers pick the right policies. They offer telematics programs to save good drivers up to 40%.

Grange Insurance

Grange Insurance offers auto, home, life, business and farm insurance to Coshocton residents and businesses. Founded in 1935, Grange has grown to serve policyholders in 13 states while maintaining strong Midwest roots.

Rated A (Excellent) by AM Best, Grange Insurance has an impressive history of financial strength. Customer reviews praise their reasonable rates and excellent claims services.

Local Grange agents provide personalized service tailored to each customer’s unique insurance needs. Grange offers savings for multi-policy, safe driving, home alarms and more.


Known for innovative options like Name Your Price® tool and Snapshot® telematics program, Progressive provides auto and home insurance nationwide including Coshocton.

With an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best, Progressive is praised for efficient claims handling using mobile and online tools. They also receive high marks for customer satisfaction.

Progressive offers a range of discounts based on safe driving, paperless billing, paying in full, and more. With competitive rates and 24/7 support, Progressive covers over 10 million drivers across the U.S.


Operating in Coshocton for over 60 years, Allstate provides auto, property, business and life insurance products. Customers benefit from their local agents’ knowledge of Coshocton insurance needs.

Allstate has an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best. J.D. Power ranked them above average in both auto and home insurance customer satisfaction.

Allstate offers accident forgiveness, safe driving bonuses, and bundled policy discounts. Their Claims Satisfaction Guarantee promises quick and fair claims resolution.

Westfield Insurance

Headquartered in Ohio, Westfield Insurance provides business, home, auto, and farm insurance across the state. With exceptional financial strength, they have an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best.

Westfield partners with local independent agencies to offer Coshocton customers personalized service. Available discounts include multi-policy, paying in full, new home, and Claim-Free Rewards.

With roots dating back to 1848, Westfield Insurance understands the insurance needs of Ohio residents and businesses. They offer value-added services like identity protection and travel assistance.

Safeco Insurance

Founded in 1923, Safeco sells insurance products through independent agents nationwide. In Coshocton, Safeco provides auto, homeowners, renters, condo, and umbrella insurance.

Safeco has an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best. Customers give positive feedback for reasonable rates and efficient claim resolution.

Withdiscounts for multi-policy, security systems, and accident forgiveness, Safeco makes insurance affordable. Safeco also offers valuable protections like identity theft coverage and pet injury coverage.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual is a leading property and casualty insurer with operations across the globe. Available locally in Coshocton, they offer auto, home, renters, life, business and disability policies.

With an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best, Liberty Mutual has strong financial backing. Customers benefit from using Liberty Mutual’s helpful online tools and working with knowledgeable agents.

Discounts are available for things like anti-theft devices, paying annually, insuring your home and car together, and signing documents electronically. Liberty Mutual has been helping people live safer for over 100 years.

State Auto

Founded in Ohio in 1921, State Auto has a strong presence across the state. They offer auto, home, business, farm, and life insurance.

State Auto has an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best. Customers can bundle policies together to save even more. Available discounts include multi-car, safe driving, anti-theft devices, and appearance retention for older cars.

Working with independent agents provides Coshocton customers with personalized local service. State Auto makes it easy to manage your policies through their user-friendly website and mobile app.

Cincinnati Insurance

Operating since 1950, Cincinnati Insurance offers property casualty and life insurance across the U.S. Available locally in Coshocton, they provide auto, home, business, and umbrella insurance.

With an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best, Cincinnati Insurance has exceptional financial strength. Policyholders can access helpful risk management tools and resources through their website.

Cincinnati Insurance partners with independent agencies to provide customized insurance packages. Bundling policies together saves customers up to 16%. Other discounts include multi-car, paid in full, and claims free renewal.

How to Choose the Right Insurer in Coshocton

With many great insurance options in Coshocton, it can be hard to select the best company for your needs. Here are some tips for choosing the right insurer:

  • Review financial strength ratings to ensure the company is stable. AM Best, Moody’s, and Standard & Poor’s are leading rating agencies.

  • Checkpolicy offerings and programs to ensure they have the coverage you need.

  • Compare customer satisfaction scores on sites like J.D. Power. This indicates how existing clients rate their experiences.

  • Look for discounts that apply to you to maximize savings.

  • Consider any value-added services and resources that could prove useful.

  • Ask friends and local agents for recommendations based on first-hand experiences.

Taking the time to research insurers operating in Coshocton allows you to make an informed insurance decision. Partnering with the right insurance company provides comprehensive protection, excellent service, and peace of mind.

Top Best Life Insurance Companies in Ohio, OH, United States


What ranking is Erie Insurance?

ERIE earned the highest homeowners insurance ranking of all rank-eligible property and casualty (P&C) carriers with a score of 856 on J.D. Power’s 1,000-point scale. That’s 37 points higher than the homeowners insurance segment average for 2023.

How many insurance agencies are in Illinois?

With 1135 independent agencies in Illinois, rest assured our recommended agents offer you more options, better value and they’re local.

Leave a Comment