Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Clearwater, Florida

Clearwater, located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is a popular retirement and vacation destination known for its beautiful beaches, warm weather, and laidback lifestyle. With a population of over 115,000 residents, Clearwater offers small town charm along with big city amenities.

As a fast-growing community with a mix of retirees, families, and professionals, finding the right insurance coverage is important for Clearwater residents. The city is prone to tropical storms and hurricanes, so having proper homeowners or renters insurance is a must. And with congested roads and highways, auto insurance is also critical.

But with so many insurance companies to choose from, how do you find the best insurer for your needs in Clearwater? Here is an overview of the top insurance providers in Clearwater, Florida and what coverage options they offer:

Major National Insurance Companies in Clearwater

Several large national insurance carriers have a strong presence in Clearwater and throughout Florida. These companies offer a full range of insurance products.

State Farm

  • Auto, homeowners, renters, condo, flood, umbrella, life, health, business
  • One of the largest insurers in Florida
  • Strong financial ratings
  • Discount programs like Drive Safe & Save


  • Auto, homeowners, renters, condo, motorcycle, boat, umbrella, life
  • Extensive local agent network
  • Options for bundled policies
  • Accident forgiveness auto feature


  • Auto, homeowners, renters, condo, umbrella, motorcycle
  • Known for low rates and creative advertising
  • Easy online quotes and policy management
  • Numerous auto discounts available


  • Auto, motorcycle, homeowners, renters, condo, umbrella
  • Competitive rates with plenty of discounts
  • User-friendly online tools and apps
  • Name Your Price® tool allows customized auto quotes


  • Auto, homeowners, renters, condo, valuable possessions, umbrella
  • Only for military members and their families
  • Consistently top-ranked for customer satisfaction
  • Bundles policies for added discounts

Top Florida-Based Insurance Companies

Residents should also consider Florida-based insurers, as they understand the unique needs of local property owners and drivers.

Citizens Property Insurance Corporation

  • Homeowners, condo, renters, flood
  • Florida’s insurer of last resort
  • High-risk or coastal properties
  • Rates regulated by the state

People’s Trust Insurance

  • Homeowners, condo, renters, flood, business
  • Florida company with discounts for hurricane mitigation
  • High marks for customer satisfaction
  • Policies available along entire Florida coast

American Integrity Insurance

  • Homeowners, condo, renters
  • Florida-based, highly rated by AM Best
  • Policy discounts include wind mitigation and age of home
  • Use local independent agents for service

United Property & Casualty

  • Homeowners, condo, renters, flood
  • Florida company with over 350,000 policies statewide
  • Policy discounts for hurricane resistance
  • High ratings for financial strength

Florida Peninsula Insurance

  • Homeowners, condo, renters
  • Florida insurer providing coastal coverage
  • Wind mitigation and multi-policy discounts
  • Claims service centers across the state

Clearwater Agents Offering Choice

In addition to the major carriers, local independent insurance agencies in Clearwater give residents an excellent selection of insurers to choose from, along with personalized service. These agencies represent multiple insurance companies, finding customers the best fit.

Brightway Insurance

  • Works with over 100 insurance carriers
  • Coverage options: auto, home, condo, renters, business
  • Local office with agents licensed across Florida

Condon-Meek Insurance

  • Independent agency serving Clearwater since 1946
  • Represents over 15 top national and regional insurers
  • Trusted for auto, home, life, business insurance

Turner Insurance Advisors

  • Family-owned agency helping Clearwater clients since 1982
  • Broad range of personal and commercial coverage
  • Proud partner of Nationwide Insurance

Insurance Office of America

  • National brokerage with a local Clearwater office
  • Home, auto, life, health, business policies
  • Access to 100+ highly rated insurance companies

Choosing the Best Insurer in Clearwater

With coverage from top national brands, Florida companies, and local agencies/brokers to select from, Clearwater residents can find an insurance provider that meets their needs and budget.

Key things to consider when picking an insurance company in Clearwater:

  • Coverage offered – Make sure the insurer provides the policies you need.

  • Prices and discounts – Obtain quotes from multiple insurers to compare rates. Ask about all available discounts.

  • Reputation and ratings – Select a highly-rated company known for quality coverage and customer satisfaction.

  • Local agents – For help choosing a policy, connecting with a local insurance agent can be invaluable.

Doing your research and understanding your specific insurance needs in Clearwater is vital to getting the right protection at the best rate. Don’t just automatically go with the cheapest option and look beyond brand names.

Speak with trusted agents in Clearwater to receive expert guidance tailored to your situation. This will provide you peace of mind knowing you have the optimal coverage in place for your home, car, business, and family. With the right insurance partner, you can feel secure as part of the Clearwater community.

Frequently Asked Questions About Clearwater Insurance

What kinds of insurance do I need living in Clearwater?

  • Homeowners or renters insurance is essential to protect your property and belongings. Florida also requires flood insurance in high-risk areas.

  • Auto insurance is mandatory in Florida and helps pay for damages if you’re in an accident.

  • Boats and RVs also need insured. And consider umbrella insurance for extra liability coverage.

How much is car insurance in Clearwater?

  • The average annual car insurance premium in Clearwater is around $1,450 per year or about $120 monthly. Rates can vary based on your age, vehicle, driving record and other factors.

What auto insurance is required in Clearwater, FL?

  • Florida requires bodily injury liability coverage of $10,000 per person, $20,000 per accident and property damage liability of $10,000. You must show proof of insurance any time you register a vehicle.

How much is homeowners insurance in Clearwater?

  • The typical Clearwater homeowner pays around $2,000 per year for homeowners insurance. Costs depend on the value/size of your home, location, coverage amount and other variables.

What factors impact insurance rates in Clearwater?

Some elements that can increase or decrease your insurance premiums in Clearwater include your credit score, home wind mitigation features, having prior claims, bundling policies, your driving record, and more.

How can I save on Clearwater insurance?

  • Shop around with different insurers to compare rates. Ask about all available discounts. Raise your deductible. Bundle multiple policies. Maintain good credit. Take defensive driver courses. Compare quotes regularly.

What are the top rated insurance companies in Clearwater?

  • Some of the highest rated insurers based on financial strength, customer service, and coverages include State Farm, USAA, Allstate, Progressive, American Integrity, Florida Peninsula, and People’s Trust.

The Bottom Line

Finding affordable, quality insurance in Clearwater, FL starts with understanding your risks and coverage needs. Comparing quotes from highly rated national brands as well as Florida insurers can help you get the lowest premium. Working with a local independent insurance agent provides expertise. Follow these tips to secure the right protection for your home, car, boat, or business in Clearwater.

Insurance companies are leaving Florida. What can be done?


Who has the cheapest car insurance in Florida?

The cheapest car insurance companies in Florida include State Farm, Geico, Travelers, Farmers and Progressive.

Who is the largest home insurer in Florida?

1. Universal Insurance Holdings Inc.

Which car insurance company has the highest customer satisfaction in Florida?

Best Customer Satisfaction in Florida: Allstate This shows that across all brands, Allstate ranks highly in Florida for customer service satisfaction.

What is the ideal car insurance coverage in Florida?

If you have sizable assets, you should have more coverage. Recommendation: $100,000 per person/$300,000 per incident, minimum.

Leave a Comment