Affordable Excitement: The Best Sports Cars to Insure on a Budget

Sports cars deliver an unbeatable adrenaline rush behind the wheel. But those thrills sometimes come with painfully high insurance costs. Exotic models can carry premiums over $4,000 per year!

Luckily, not all sports cars break the bank to insure. The right model can offer an invigorating driving experience without sky-high rates.

This guide reveals the most affordable sports cars to insure. We’ll look at:

  • Budget-friendly sports cars by type
  • Factors that affect insurance costs
  • Tips to lower your premiums
  • Pros and cons of sports car insurance
  • Frequently asked questions

With the right information, you can find an exciting ride that won’t drain your wallet on insurance.

Cheapest Sports Cars to Insure by Type

Here are top affordable options in popular sports car categories:

Cheap Roadsters

  • Mazda MX-5 Miata
  • Fiat 124 Spider
  • Toyota 86

Roadsters deliver wind-in-your-hair thrills without massive insurance bills. The Miata and 86 cost under $1,500 per year to insure on average.

Affordable Hot Hatches

  • Volkswagen Golf GTI
  • Mini Cooper S
  • Hyundai Veloster Turbo

Hot hatches blend practicality and excitement. The Golf GTI strikes the best balance, with average insurance costs around $1,600 annually.

Budget-Friendly Coupes

  • Ford Mustang EcoBoost
  • Chevrolet Camaro LT1
  • Dodge Challenger SXT

The pony car rivals all offer affordable V6 trims. Expect yearly rates around $2,000 for the Camaro LT1 and Mustang EcoBoost.

Low-Cost Sport Compacts

  • Subaru BRZ
  • Volkswagen GTI
  • Mazda 3

The BRZ and GTI provide rear-wheel drive thrills without the financial pain, costing $1,400 to $1,600 per year on average.

What Impacts Sports Car Insurance Costs?

Sports cars are more expensive to insure than typical family sedans and SUVs. But many factors impact your premiums, including:

Power and Performance

More horsepower equals higher rates in most cases. But power isn’t everything – a BRZ costs similar to insure as a WRX despite having half the horsepower.

Vehicle Value

A more expensive vehicle has higher repair and replacement costs, increasing premiums. But advanced safety tech can help offset this.

Safety Ratings

Good crash test results show a vehicle protects occupants well, lowering injury risk. This cuts premium costs. Poor ratings raise them.

Repair Frequency

Sports cars tend to have higher claim frequencies, especially for collisions. Models with high annual repair costs have pricier premiums.

Driver Age

Insurers view young drivers as riskier behind the wheel. Under 25 sports car owners get hit with steeper rates.

Driving Record

A clean record with no tickets, accidents or claims saves you money. Violations and accidents raise your premium significantly.

Tips to Lower Sports Car Insurance Costs

Use these strategies to trim your insurance costs:

  • Shop around for quotes – rates vary widely between insurers.

  • Ask about discounts – options like multi-policy and safe driver discounts can help lower your premium.

  • Raise your deductible – this cuts rates at the expense of higher out-of-pocket costs if you file a claim.

  • Improve your credit score – insurers charge more for poor credit, so boosting your score can save you money.

  • Become a low-mileage driver – fewer miles driven annually means lower risk to insurers.

  • Install anti-theft devices – this makes your car less appealing to thieves, reducing comprehensive claims.

The Pros and Cons of Insuring a Sports Car

Here are some key advantages and disadvantages to weigh:


  • Enjoy an exciting driving experience
  • Customize and personalize your ride
  • Improve bad driving habits due to focused handling
  • Possible discounts for safety features and driver training courses


  • Much higher insurance premiums, especially for young drivers
  • Easier to exceed speed limits and drive recklessly
  • Higher repair costs after an accident
  • Greater risk of theft

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is insurance for a high-end sports car?

Luxury models like the Porsche 911 have astronomical rates, often $4,000+ per year. The Ferrari F8 Spider tops $5,000 annually on average.

Are 2-door sports cars more expensive to insure?

Yes, coupes cost more than 4-door models to insure. The body style is associated with speed and power, raising premiums.

Is a classic sports car cheaper to insure?

Not necessarily. Classic car insurance costs more due to limited use and higher vehicle value. But you may be able to save by limiting mileage or reducing coverage.

Can safety features help lower sports car insurance?

Yes, advanced driver assists like automatic emergency braking can offset the higher risk of insuring a sports car. Ask your insurer about safety discounts.

Does car color impact sports car insurance costs?

Yes, red sports cars have the highest insurance rates. Eye-catching colors indicate aggressive driving, increasing premiums. Neutral shades like white and silver are cheaper.

Find the Best Sports Car Insurance Rates

You can balance the excitement of a sports car with affordable insurance premiums. Focus on budget models with good safety scores and shop carefully to minimize costs.

To find your best rate, compare quotes from multiple top insurers. Enter your zip code below to get free, personalized sports car insurance estimates to kickstart your search!

The BEST Cheap Sports Cars!


Are sports cars higher insurance?

Car insurance costs vary widely based on a vehicle’s make and model. Sports car owners are likely to pay a higher premium for auto insurance. The steeper cost for sports cars is due in part to the fact that auto insurers recognize that sports cars have a higher risk for: Collision damage.

What is the cheapest sports car insurance?

Cheapest sports car insurance companies Progressive has the cheapest performance car insurance, averaging $215 per month for full coverage. That’s 30% cheaper than the average cost of insurance for sports cars, which is $305 per month. It’s also 24% cheaper than the second-cheapest company, Geico.

Leave a Comment