The Best Insurance Companies in Charleston, SC

Charleston is a historic coastal city known for its charming architecture, cobblestone streets, and southern hospitality. But living in this beautiful location comes with risks like hurricanes, flooding, and theft that make insurance coverage essential.

Finding the right insurance company for your needs can be tricky with so many options. To help Charleston residents, in this comprehensive guide we review the top insurers serving the area across auto, home, life, and specialty insurance.

Factors to Consider in Charleston Insurance Companies

When evaluating insurers in Charleston, here are some key factors to look for:

  • Cost – Compare quotes to find the most affordable rates.

  • Discounts – Maximize savings through bundling and other discounts.

  • Coverage options – Make sure the insurer offers the protections you need.

  • Customer service – Seek companies with high satisfaction scores.

  • Local agents – Use an insurer with Charleston-based agents who know the area.

  • Financial strength – Choose an established company able to pay claims.

Keeping these criteria in mind, below we showcase the top insurance providers in Charleston and highlight the best for different types of coverage.

The Best Auto Insurance Companies in Charleston

Since nearly all residents rely on vehicles to get around the sprawling Charleston metro area, quality auto insurance is essential. Here are the top picks:

  • State Farm – Offers low rates and has highly-rated local agents in Charleston.

  • Allstate – Features accident forgiveness and safe driving rewards programs.

  • GEICO – Delivers some of the cheapest auto insurance quotes in the state.

  • Progressive – Leading insurer known for affordability and convenience.

  • Nationwide – Provides usage-based SmartRide discounts and accident forgiveness.

When getting quotes, be sure to ask about discounts to lower your premiums, such as for bundling home and auto insurance. State Farm and Nationwide agents will help you maximize savings.

The Best Home Insurance Companies in Charleston

Charleston’s coastal location makes strong home insurance a must. Top insurers include:

  • Allstate – Comprehensive flood coverage options plus smart home tech discounts.

  • State Farm – Highly rated for claims satisfaction with unique rider options.

  • Nationwide – Covers hurricanes and offers Brand New Belongings replacement coverage.

  • Travelers – Top-notch financial strength and specialty high-value home coverage.

  • USAA – Only for military but consistently earns best-in-class customer satisfaction.

Be sure to inquire about hurricane, flood, and water backup protections to safeguard your home. State Farm, Allstate, and Nationwide agents can guide you.

The Best Life Insurance Companies in Charleston

Protecting family following a loss requires solid life insurance, available from:

  • State Farm – Most popular for its affordable term life insurance rates.

  • New York Life – Highly-rated mutual company with permanent and term options.

  • Northwestern Mutual – Whole life policies that build cash value over time.

  • MassMutual – Term, whole, and universal life insurance plus living benefits.

  • Pacific Life – Flexible permanent and term life insurance choices.

Local agents from State Farm or Northwestern Mutual can estimate costs and help you determine sufficient coverage amounts.

Specialty Insurance Companies in Charleston

For specific insurance needs, these Charleston providers lead their niche:

  • Boat – Geico, Progressive, Allstate
  • Business – The Hartford, Travelers, Nationwide
  • Health – BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina, Ambetter, Molina
  • Renters – State Farm, Allstate, Travelers
  • Motorcycle – Geico, Progressive, Foremost

Tips for Finding the Best Insurance in Charleston

Follow these best practices when shopping for coverage:

  • Compare quotes from at least 3 top insurers to find the lowest price.
  • Ask about all available discounts to maximize savings.
  • Work with local agents who understand Charleston’s unique risks.
  • Verify the company has strong financial ratings.
  • Check customer feedback using ratings on review sites.
  • Look for providers that simplify payments and claims filing.

The Top 5 Insurance Companies in Charleston

  1. State Farm
  2. Allstate
  3. Nationwide
  4. GEICO
  5. Progressive

Using this guide’s analysis, Charleston residents can narrow down the best insurance companies for their needs and make an informed choice. Comparing multiple quotes and an insurer’s customer service reputation is key. But doing your due diligence ensures you get optimal coverage at the lowest cost from a reputable provider.

The 5 BEST Auto Insurance Companies


Who is the most trusted insurance company?

Insurance company
Best for
Bankrate Score
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best for military-focused coverage
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Best for added perks
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5

How much is car insurance in Charleston SC?

The average cost of a car insurance policy in Charleston is $735 per six-month policy — $122 per month. The cheapest company in Charleston is Georgia Farm Bureau ($588).

Is homeowners insurance expensive in Charleston SC?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Charleston is approximately $3,200 per year for dwelling coverage of up to $500,000.

Leave a Comment