How an Expired Registration Ticket Can Affect Your Car Insurance Rates

Getting pulled over is never fun, but it’s especially stressful when the reason is an expired registration. While driving with expired tags is usually just a fix-it ticket, it can still impact your auto insurance rates. Here’s what you need to know about how an expired registration ticket could affect your car insurance.

Why Do Registration Tickets Affect Insurance?

Insurance companies regularly check motor vehicle records to see each driver’s history of traffic violations and accidents. Tickets and accidents are both signals of higher risk, so insurers tend to raise rates when they see them.

Registration tickets specifically point to irresponsible vehicle maintenance and a disregard for the rules of the road. Insurers tend to see drivers with expired registration as more likely to:

  • Forget other important car maintenance needs like oil changes, tire rotations, etc. Lack of maintenance leads to more mechanical problems and accidents.

  • Commit other violations like speeding or ignoring traffic signs. Disregard for registration rules suggests disregard for other rules too.

  • Try to avoid consequences by not reporting an accident. Unregistered drivers may try to handle accidents “off the books” to avoid penalties.

While a single expired registration ticket doesn’t guarantee these behaviors, insurers use them as predictors of future claim likelihood. The more violations and accidents you have, the riskier you look on paper.

How Much Rates Increase After a Registration Ticket

On average, a ticket for an expired registration leads to about a 5% – 15% increase in insurance rates. However, the exact amount depends on several factors:

  • Driving Record: Drivers with clean records tend to see smaller increases than those with prior tickets or claims. One ticket stands out more on an otherwise clean record.

  • Insurance Company: Some insurers penalize tickets more harshly than others. Comparing quotes after a ticket can help find a company with lower surcharges.

  • State: Insurance regulations differ by state, so rate hikes for the same ticket can vary quite a bit between states.

  • Vehicle Use: Drivers who use their car for commuting or business will tend to see larger rate hikes than those who drive primarily for pleasure. More miles driven means more exposure.

  • Discounts Lost: Surcharges for tickets can cause drivers to lose out on safe driver or violation-free discounts they previously qualified for. This further increases rates.

While a 10% increase may not seem huge, it can add up fast, especially for high-risk drivers already paying thousands per year. Shopping around is wise after any driving violation to find the best value.

How Long a Registration Ticket Affects Your Rates

In most states, tickets and accidents remain on your motor vehicle record for 3-5 years. Insurance companies will apply surcharges for violations as long as they appear on your MVR.

However, the impact of a violation typically decreases each year. For example, a 10% hike in year one might shrink to 7% in year two and 3% in year three. Eventually the ticket “ages off” your record and no longer impacts your rates.

Some insurers may continue showing small residual rate increases even after tickets fall off your MVR. While tickets over 5 years old won’t directly impact your premium, insurers may still consider your full history when setting rates.

The bottom line is an expired registration ticket could influence your car insurance rates for up to 5 years. The sooner you can get a clean record after the ticket, the faster your rates will start decreasing.

How to Minimize the Rate Increase After a Registration Ticket

While an expired registration ticket will likely raise your rates to some degree, there are things you can do to minimize the damage:

  • Fix the Issue: Immediately get your registration renewed to show you’ve fixed the problem. This prevents escalating penalties for continuing to drive unregistered.

  • Select a Forgiving Insurer: Shop quotes and compare how different insurers handle the ticket. Select one that offers the lowest surcharge.

  • Ask About Discounts: Inquire about discounts like defensive driver courses or low mileage that could help offset the rate hike.

  • Increase Your Deductible: Raising your deductible from $500 to $1000 could shave 10% or more off your premium. This can help absorb a ticket surcharge.

  • Improve Your Habits: Focus on stellar driving habits to keep a clean record after the ticket. This will help your rates rebound faster.

  • Compare Quotes Regularly: Shop for cheaper rates at every renewal to minimize how much a ticket affects your bottom line.

While an expired registration ticket can hurt your rates for a few years, smart shopping habits can reduce the sting. Maintaining a clean record after the violation will get your rates trending down over time.

Can You Fight an Expired Registration Ticket?

In some cases, it may be possible to fight an expired registration ticket in court to avoid both fines and insurance impacts. The chances of success depend on the specifics of your situation. Here are some common defenses against registration tickets:

  • Valid Registration: If you actually had up-to-date tags but left your registration card at home, you may be able to get the ticket dismissed. Bringing proof of registration to your court date is key.

  • Grace Period: Some states allow for a grace period after registration expires where you can still drive legally with the old tags. If you were within this window when ticketed, point this out to the judge.

  • Financial Hardship: Judges may dismiss registration tickets if you lacked the funds to renew at the time, but have since renewed. Evidence you couldn’t afford to renew but fixed it ASAP helps.

  • Renewal Notice Issues: If the DMV failed to send your registration renewal notice, resulting in unintentional expired tags, judges may dismiss the ticket. Your efforts to renew once notified are key.

  • Other Mitigating Circumstances: Special situations like medical emergencies, military service, or DMV errors could persuade a judge to dismiss the ticket.

The odds of getting a registration ticket dismissed vary case by case. Speaking with a local traffic attorney can help assess if you have a shot. But even if the ticket sticks, taking actions to improve your driving record and control premiums can minimize the insurance impact.

How Else Tickets and Violations Affect Your Insurance

Beyond registration issues, many other tickets and violations can influence your car insurance rates. Common examples include:

  • Speeding Tickets – One of the most frequent violations that can increase insurance premiums by 10% or more for several years.

  • DUI/DWI – A major violation that can raise rates by 80% or more for many years due to the high risk involved. May also lead to revoked licenses.

  • Reckless Driving – Citations for swerving, street racing, or other reckless behaviors can result in steep rate hikes.

  • Distracted Driving – Tickets for cell phone use, texting, or other distractions while driving boost insurance costs.

  • License Suspensions – Suspended licenses are red flags to insurers, often leading to non-renewal or large rate hikes if coverage continues.

  • At-Fault Accidents – Accidents where you are deemed at-fault raise insurance rates due to higher perceived risk.

The more tickets and other violations you accumulate, the higher your car insurance is likely to climb over time. Following the rules of the road is key to controlling costs.

Impact on High-Risk Insurance Rates

Drivers deemed high-risk already pay higher insurance rates due to past tickets, accidents, or other factors. An expired registration ticket causes larger rate spikes for high-risk drivers compared to those with clean records.

Someone with numerous speeding tickets and past accidents could see a 20% – 30% hike after another violation. Meanwhile, a driver with a perfect record may only face a 5% increase.

High-risk drivers tend to have fewer options for affordable coverage. Too many violations can make some standard insurers unwilling to offer a policy at all. Specialty non-standard auto insurance companies or state risk pools become the only options.

An expired registration ticket alone won’t necessarily cause you to be labeled high-risk. But for drivers already paying high rates, such a ticket along with other violations can lead to spiraling insurance costs. Improving your driving habits is key to get back on track after mistakes.

When to Consult an Attorney About Tickets

Traffic tickets of any kind have the potential to inflame your insurance rates and cause administrative hassles like suspended licenses if you fail to act. Consulting with a lawyer is wise in situations such as:

  • You believe you were incorrectly or unjustly ticketed and want to build a strong case for dismissal.

  • You are accused of a major violation like DUI that could severely impact your rates and driving privileges if it sticks.

  • You already have a lengthy violation history and can’t afford the insurance spike of another ticket.

  • You don’t fully understand the ramifications of a ticket and want advice on your best options.

  • You plan to fight a ticket on your own in court and want coaching on the most effective strategies.

Keep in mind that hiring a traffic ticket attorney doesn’t necessarily guarantee

I received a ticket in my friend’s car because their registration was expired. Is that fair?


What happens if your registration expires in NY?

If your registration has been expired for less than 60 days the fine is at least $40 and can go up to $300 and an automatic $93 surcharge. If your registration has been expired for more than 60 days the fine is at least $70 and can go up to $300 along with the $93 surcharge.

What happens if you get pulled over with expired registration in California?

Brief Synopsis: Driving with expired registration (Vehicle Code § 5204(a)) is an infraction with a fine of $25, plus penalties and assessments (total perhaps $173 in late 2018). If the registration expired over six months earlier, police may impound the vehicle. There are no DMV points associated with this violation.

What happens if you get a ticket for expired registration in Texas?

If you received a citation for an vehicle expired registration, you must appear at the Municipal Court on or before the appearance date listed on your citation. You may present proof of correction of the defect, pay an administrative fine of $20 and the citation may be dismissed.

How much is a ticket for expired tags in Ohio?

Fines and Penalties: In Ohio, the fines for driving with expired tags can range from $100 to $150. However, additional court costs can push the total penalty higher.

Leave a Comment