Finding the Best Car Insurance in Dayton, Ohio

Dayton is Ohio’s sixth-largest city, with a population of around 140,000. As the birthplace of aviation and home to the National Museum of the U.S. Air Force, Dayton has a rich history and plenty to offer residents and visitors.

But with all those drivers on the road, getting the right car insurance coverage at the best price is crucial in Dayton. Here’s what you need to know about shopping for car insurance in Dayton and finding the policy that fits your needs and budget.

Average Cost of Car Insurance in Dayton

Car insurance rates in Dayton are on the lower side compared to the rest of the state. The average annual cost of minimum liability car insurance in Dayton is $465, which is below the state average of $582. For full coverage car insurance, the average annual cost is $1,459, also less than the Ohio average of $1,698.

Here are some of the factors that affect car insurance costs in Dayton:

  • Your age: Teenage drivers pay the highest rates in Dayton, with an average annual bill of $2,201. Drivers in their 50s and 60s enjoy the lowest rates.

  • Your gender: Men generally pay more for car insurance than women in the same age group.

  • Your marital status: Married drivers tend to get better rates than single drivers.

  • Your driving record: Drivers with accidents, speeding tickets, or DUIs pay significantly higher premiums.

  • Your credit score: Insurers often use credit-based insurance scores to set rates. Better scores mean better rates.

  • Your car: Insuring luxury cars, sports cars, or vehicles with high theft rates costs more.

  • Your mileage: Drivers who commute long distances pay more than those with low annual mileage.

  • Where you live: Urban areas like Dayton may have slightly higher premiums than suburban or rural zip codes.

  • Discounts: Taking defensive driving courses, bundling policies, having anti-theft devices, and maintaining good grades can lower your costs.

Minimum Car Insurance Requirements in Ohio

Under Ohio law, all drivers are required to carry the following minimum liability insurance coverage:

  • $25,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $25,000 property damage liability

This coverage protects other drivers if you cause an accident. It does NOT cover damage to your own car or injuries to you or your passengers.

For that, you need collision and comprehensive coverage. These optional coverages pay for damage to your vehicle from collisions, theft, vandalism, fire, floods, hail, and more.

You may also want to consider:

  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage
  • Medical payments or personal injury protection
  • Rental reimbursement
  • Roadside assistance

Work with your insurer or agent to select limits and deductibles that fit your budget. Higher deductibles lower your premium but mean more out-of-pocket costs if you file a claim.

Top 5 Car Insurers in Dayton

The five largest car insurance companies in Dayton are:

  1. State Farm: With 18% market share, State Farm insures the most Dayton drivers. They offer standard policies plus usage-based options that can save safe drivers up to 30%.

  2. Progressive: Known for online quoting and claims reporting, Progressive holds 13% of the Dayton market. They offer plenty of discounts and even snapshot rate plans based on driving habits.

  3. Allstate: Allstate has a reputation for good customer service and an extensive local agent network. They hold 8% of the market in Dayton.

  4. Nationwide: Headquartered in Columbus, Nationwide is Ohio’s homegrown insurer. They have 7% market share in Dayton.

  5. GEICO: With effective advertising and low rates, especially for military members, GEICO captures 7% of Dayton drivers. They focus on online and phone-based customer service.

While these top five companies hold over half the market, don’t rule out smaller national and regional insurers. Companies like Liberty Mutual, Travelers, The Hartford, and Grange may offer just the right mix of coverage, service, and pricing for your situation.

How to Get the Best Car Insurance Rates in Dayton

Here are some proven tips for locking in the lowest auto insurance rates in Dayton:

  • Compare quotes from at least three insurers. Rates can vary dramatically, so shop around. Get quotes from large national insurers plus regional and local companies.

  • Ask about all available discounts. Let the insurer know if you’re a homeowner, good student, married, senior, loyal customer with another company, etc.

  • Select higher deductibles. Going from a $500 deductible to $1000 could save 15% or more. Just be sure you have savings to cover the higher out-of-pocket costs.

  • Limit your mileage. If you drive less than 7,500 miles a year, ask about low-mileage discounts.

  • Ask about usage-based programs. Insurers like Progressive and State Farm offer rates based on actual driving behavior recorded by an app or device. Good driving means savings between 10-30%.

  • Maintain good credit. Get free copies of your credit reports and keep your credit score as high as possible to qualify for the best rates.

  • Enroll in defensive driver programs. Completing motor vehicle accident prevention courses can earn a discount.

  • Inquire about discounts. Don’t assume you won’t qualify. Ask your insurer about all possible ways to lower your premium.

  • Compare rates every renewal. Shop around again before your policy renews to ensure you still have the best deal.

How to File a Car Insurance Claim in Dayton

If you need to file an auto insurance claim in Dayton, follow these steps for the best outcome:

  • Report the accident or loss immediately. Notify your insurer right away, even if it seems minor. Delays can raise suspicions and complicate the claims process.

  • Document the damage. Take photos or video of the vehicle damage, accident scene, or any property that was damaged. Get a police report for accidents.

  • Locate your policy and any related paperwork. Review coverages, limits, and deductibles so you know what to expect.

  • Cooperate fully with your adjuster. Provide any additional documentation your insurer requests. Communicate openly so the adjuster can accurately assess the claim.

  • Get repair estimates. Your insurer will ask you to get estimates from approved auto body shops. Ask the shop about warranties on workmanship.

  • Settle on the amount. Negotiate a fair settlement if the initial offer seems too low, but avoid exaggerating or inflating costs.

  • Accept the payment. Review the documentation, sign any required forms, and accept the payment according to the timeframe in your policy.

  • Make repairs. Schedule the work with the repair shop. Pay your deductible and co-pays.

Following these steps helps ensure you receive fair claim payments within the terms of your policy. For a smoother experience, choose a top-rated insurer known for effective claims handling.

Top Car Insurance Companies in Dayton

To find the best fit for your situation, consider the top insurers offering coverage to Dayton drivers:

State Farm

  • Over 3,400 agents in Ohio
  • Usage-based Drive Safe & SaveTM program
  • Strong claims satisfaction scores
  • Competitive rates including many discounts
  • Auto, home, and life insurance bundles


  • Digital tools for getting quotes, managing policies, and filing claims
  • Name Your Price® tool provides customized rate options
  • Snapshot® program offers discounted rates for safe driving
  • Concierge level claims service available


  • 1,000+ agents across Ohio
  • Options for accident forgiveness and safe driving bonuses
  • Ride for Hire coverage for Uber/Lyft drivers
  • Bundling with home and renters insurance


  • 1100+ local agents in Ohio
  • Vanishing deductible reward for claim-free driving
  • SmartRide program measures driving habits
  • Comprehensive coverage including ridesharing and rental cars


  • Low rates with extensive online/mobile account management
  • Mechanical breakdown insurance available
  • Accident forgiveness to avoid rate hikes after your first accident
  • Numerous policy discounts and reward programs

Liberty Mutual

  • Coverage starting at $50/month
  • Accident forgiveness with collisions outside your control
  • Deductible rewards to lower collision deductible over time
  • New car replacement for recently purchased vehicles


  • Discounts for hybrid/electric vehicles
  • E-sign discount for paperless documents
  • Claim-free driving bonus after five years
  • New car replacement coverage included

Key Takeaways

  • Shop around and compare quotes from national, regional, and local insurers in Dayton. Rates can vary widely.

  • Ohio requires liability coverage but

Car Insurance in Dayton, Ohio


Who has the cheapest car insurance in Ohio?

Cheapest full coverage car insurance in Ohio: State Farm State Farm is the best cheap auto insurance company in Ohio for full coverage, with an average rate of $70 per month. State Farm is 37% cheaper than the state average and $7 cheaper than the next-cheapest insurer, Erie.

How much is car insurance per month in Ohio?

The average cost of car insurance in Ohio is $1,599 per year or $133 per month for a full-coverage policy, while minimum coverage costs $536 per year or $45 per month. The best way to get cheap insurance in Ohio is to shop around and compare car insurance quotes.

Who gives the lowest car insurance rates?

State Farm is the cheapest large auto insurance company in the nation for good drivers, according to NerdWallet’s 2024 analysis of minimum coverage rates. State Farm’s average annual rate was $471 or about $39 per month.

Why is car insurance so cheap in Ohio?

Car insurance in Ohio is actually not very expensive compared to the national average, thanks to its population of safe drivers and a saturated, competitive insurance market.

Leave a Comment