Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Newark, New Jersey

Newark is New Jersey’s largest city and a major business hub in the New York City metro area. With a population of over 280,000, Newark has a diverse mix of residents and businesses that need insurance. This article provides an overview of major insurance companies in Newark and tips for finding the right insurer for your needs.

Auto Insurance in Newark

Driving in Newark requires carrying at least the state minimum auto insurance coverage:

  • $15,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $30,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $5,000 property damage liability

Many experts recommend carrying more than just the minimums for better protection. When looking for car insurance in Newark, major insurers include:

  • State Farm – National company with local agents and discounts like safe driver savings.

  • Allstate – Offers Newark drivers discounts like safe driving bonus, anti-theft device, and anti-lock brakes.

  • GEICO – National insurer with discount options like defensive driver, good student, and multi-policy.

  • Progressive – Online quotes and usage-based insurance available. Discount for continuous insurance coverage.

  • Mercury Insurance – Local agents and affordable rates. Discounts for good students and multi-car policies.

Shopping around between insurers is wise, as rates can vary significantly for the same driver. Compare identical coverage amounts when pricing policies.

Home Insurance in Newark

Newark homeowners insurance provides protection against damage to your dwelling, detached structures, personal property and liability claims.

Major home insurers in Newark include:

  • Allstate – Offers replacement cost coverage for rebuilding and personal liability.

  • State Farm – Options like guaranteed replacement cost and water backup protection available.

  • Liberty Mutual – Discounts for home security systems, smart home devices, and newly built homes.

  • Travelers – Policy add-ons like identity fraud expense coverage and water backup.

  • NJM – New Jersey-based mutual insurer with additional coverages for sewer and drain backups.

Compare the inclusions, exclusions, deductibles and endorsements when evaluating home insurance companies.

Condo Insurance in Newark

Condo owners in Newark need HO-6 condo insurance. This covers your personal property, upgrades to your unit, liability and loss assessments.

Top condo insurers in Newark include:

  • Geico – Discounts offered for gated community and new home.

  • Allstate – Policies include replacement cost coverage and $100k liability.

  • State Farm – Options like water backup, guaranteed replacement cost, and identity restoration.

  • Liberty Mutual – Can bundle with car insurance for multi-policy discount.

  • Mercury – Local agents and coverage including loss assessments and $100k liability.

Review HOA rules on coverages when shopping for a Newark condo insurance policy.

Renters Insurance in Newark

Renters insurance is affordable protection for tenants against loss of personal property. Newark renters should compare:

  • USAA – Discounts for bundling renters with car insurance. Limited membership eligibility.

  • State Farm – Options like replacement cost coverage, identity restoration, and water backup.

  • Allstate – Policies include $100k liability coverage and identity theft expense.

  • Liberty Mutual – Can add coverage for high value items like jewelry and electronics.

  • Travelers – Discount for having prior renters insurance with no claims.

Look for inclusions like replacement cost and liability coverage when choosing renters insurance.

Business Insurance in Newark

Newark businesses have many insurance options including:

  • The Hartford – Policies available for general liability, property, workers’ comp and more.

  • Travelers – Flexible coverages and risk management services for Newark businesses.

  • Liberty Mutual – Options for commercial auto, liability, property, and umbrella insurance.

  • Chubb – High-limit liability, property damage, and business interruption policies.

  • Mercury Insurance – Business owners policies starting at just $27/month.

Work with an agent to build a customized insurance plan based on your Newark business’s operations and risks.

Finding the Best Insurer in Newark

Here are some tips for finding the top insurance companies in Newark for your needs:

  • Shop around and compare quotes from both national and local insurers.

  • Ask about all available discounts to maximize your savings.

  • Work with an independent agent who can compare many companies.

  • Choose an insurer that offers robust customer service resources.

  • Look for an insurer that has strong financial ratings from agencies like A.M. Best.

  • Pick an insurance provider that offers flexibility to modify your policy as needs change.

  • Read online reviews and feedback about insurance companies from current customers.

  • Make sure you understand all coverages, limitations, and exclusions before purchasing a policy.

  • Request quotes every 1-2 years at renewal time to ensure you still have the best rate.

Finding the right insurance company in Newark takes research. Be sure to invest the time to make an informed decision and secure coverage at a competitive price.

Top Auto Insurance Companies in Newark

Here is an overview of some of the major auto insurance providers in the Newark market:

State Farm

  • Largest auto insurer in the U.S.
  • Newark resident agents and 24/7 customer service.
  • Discounts like safe driving savings, anti-theft device, and defensive driving course completion.
  • Available coverages include liability, collision, comprehensive, rental reimbursement and roadside assistance.


  • Second largest auto insurer nationwide.
  • Discount options like anti-theft device, anti-lock brakes, good student, and federal employee.
  • Usage-based DriveEasy program available.
  • Mobile app and online quotes make getting a rate easy.


  • One of the biggest U.S. auto insurance companies.
  • Offers Newark drivers discounts for safe driving, anti-theft device, anti-lock brakes, and paying in full.
  • Policies include accident forgiveness, new car replacement, and customized parts replacement.


  • Fourth largest auto insurer in the U.S.
  • Snapshot usage-based program available. Discount for continuous insurance coverage.
  • Policies include coverages like custom parts replacement, rideshare coverage, and roadside assistance.

Liberty Mutual

  • Offers discounts for teens who complete driver training.
  • Can bundle home and auto policies.
  • Accident forgiveness included after 5 years of driving without an accident.
  • Coverage add-ons like rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance available.

Top Home Insurance Companies in Newark

Major home insurance providers serving Newark homeowners include:


  • Replacement cost coverage included for rebuilding after a covered loss.
  • Options to increase liability protection above $100k-$300k minimums.
  • Policies include coverage for identity theft and lock replacement.

State Farm

  • Largest home insurer in the U.S. with strong financial ratings.
  • Guaranteed replacement cost available for rebuilding your home.
  • Add-on options like water/sewer backup, equipment breakdown, and identity restoration.

Liberty Mutual

  • Discounts offered for home security systems, smart home devices, newly built homes.
  • Optional coverages for identity fraud expense, water backup, equipment breakdown.
  • Can bundle home and auto insurance together.


  • Home insurance discount for having prior Travelers renters or condo policy.
  • Availability of discounts for new home, claim-free customers, and multi-policy.
  • Additional coverages like identity fraud expense, water sewer backup, and service line coverage.


  • High-end home insurer with customized policies.
  • Coverage for replacement cost, liability, additional living expenses, flood, identity fraud.
  • Endorsements available for expensive jewelry, collections, home businesses.

Top Renters Insurance Companies in Newark

Major providers of renters insurance policies in Newark include:


  • Policies start at just $5 per month. Discounts for bundling renters with auto.
  • Standard policy includes replacement cost coverage, $15k-$30k in property coverage, $100k liability.


  • Online quotes and policies issued in minutes. Discounts for bundling policies.
  • Base policies include replacement cost coverage, $30k in property coverage, $100k liability.

State Farm

  • Largest underwriter of renters policies in the U.S.
  • Standard options include $15k-$30k in property coverage, $100k liability.
  • Add-ons available for replacement cost, water backup, identity restoration.


  • Policies start at just $15 per month. Can bundle with auto insurance.
  • $100k

The Role of Insurance Companies in Personal Injury Cases Newark NJ


Who is the most trusted insurance company?

Insurance company
Best for
Bankrate Score
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best for military-focused coverage
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Best for added perks
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5

What is the best full coverage insurance?

Based on our research, national insurer State Farm has the best cheap full-coverage car insurance. Geico offers the lowest rates, according to our study, but State Farm has the best customer ratings and the best coverage overall.

What is the best insurance to go through?

Best car insurance category
Company winner
Best overall
Best large insurer
American Family
Best perks for loyal customers
Best for accident forgiveness

Leave a Comment