Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Naperville, IL

As the fourth largest city in Illinois, Naperville offers its residents and businesses a wide range of insurance options. With over 150,000 residents, Naperville has attracted national, regional, and local insurance companies all looking to provide coverage.

But with so many choices, how do you determine the top insurance providers in Naperville for your needs? By comparing factors like financial strength, customer satisfaction, pricing, and services offered, we can highlight the standout insurance companies in Naperville across categories.

Auto Insurance in Naperville

When it comes to auto insurance, some of the top providers in Naperville include:

State Farm – As the largest auto insurer nationwide, State Farm offers familiarity and discounts. But some customers complain about claim denials.

Allstate – This national carrier provides standard auto policies as well as options like accident forgiveness. Rates can be higher than competitors.

Progressive – Known for low rates and ease of quoting/buying online. Light on local agent support.

American Family – Regional company with fewer discounts but excellent financial strength ratings.

Country Financial – Local insurer popular for bundling home and auto policies. Limited online support.

GEICO – Focuses on low cost coverage and streamlined customer experience. Some concerns over claims processes.

Liberty Mutual – Offers standard policies plus extras like custom parts coverage and roadside assistance.

For Naperville drivers, getting quotes from national brands like Progressive and GEICO as well as local choices like Country Financial is wise to find the best rate.

Homeowners Insurance in Naperville

Prominent home insurance providers in Naperville include:

Allstate – National carrier with broad coverage options including flood and earthquake policies.

State Farm – Top choice for bundled auto/home insurance. Claims handling garners low satisfaction scores.

American Family – Regional insurer with high financial strength ratings but fewer discounts.

Country Financial – Local favorite for home insurance especially outside Naperville’s core.

Travelers – Offers standard coverage plus identity fraud expense and water backup protections.

Liberty Mutual – Provides options like replacement cost for possessions and exterior home coverage.

USAA – Specializes in discounts for military members and veterans. Limited eligibility.

For the right home insurance coverage at the best price, comparing local insurers like Country Financial with national brands like Allstate is key.

Business Insurance in Naperville

Prominent business insurance providers in Naperville include:

The Hartford – Offers a broad range of commercial policies from BOP to workers’ comp.

Nationwide – Focuses on business insurance for contractors, professionals, restaurants, retailers, and more.

State Farm – Leading choice for small business bundles with auto insurance.

Travelers – Provides general liability, professional liability, cyber coverage, and more.

Liberty Mutual – Top option for commercial auto and fleet insurance policies.

COUNTRY Financial – Local favorite for farms, agriculture, and related business insurance.

Next Insurance – Specializes in tailored coverage for startups and small businesses.

Hiscox – Leader in specialized policies for professional services, IT, and creative sectors.

Naperville businesses should compare quotes from national insurers like The Hartford with local agents and online companies.

Health Insurance in Naperville

For individual and family health insurance, top options in Naperville are:

Blue Cross Blue Shield – Offers PPO and HMO plans on public Illinois exchange and direct.

UnitedHealthcare – National insurer with comprehensive plans and large provider networks.

Aetna – Leading choice for price, network strength, and customer service.

Cigna – Focuses on value-based and consumer-directed health plans.

Humana – Popular for Medicare Advantage and supplemental senior health plans.

Bright Health – Digital insurer with focus on integrated care and wellness.

Naperville residents can work with health insurance brokers or shop policies from brands like Blue Cross and Aetna on the public insurance exchange.

Life Insurance in Naperville

When it comes to life insurance, top options in Naperville include:

State Farm – Standout choice for ease of bundling with other policies.

Northwestern Mutual – Local provider known for whole life insurance and annuities.

New York Life – Top mutual company with highly rated financial strength.

Prudential – National insurer with extensive choices from term to permanent life.

Lincoln Financial – Competitive pricing and support from local financial advisors.

Ameritas – Leading regional life insurer based in Nebraska.

For the right mix of life insurance coverage at the optimal cost, compare big national brands like Prudential with local agents and advisors.

Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Naperville

Naperville residents have no shortage of insurance choices from national brands to local agencies. But reviewing company financial strength, coverage details, customer satisfaction, and costs is critical to finding the right provider.

Key tips for choosing insurance in Naperville include:

  • Compare quotes from national and local insurers
  • Check BBB reviews and financial strength ratings
  • Review policy details closely for exclusions
  • Ask about all available discounts
  • Work with trusted local insurance agents
  • Seek bundled insurance for potential savings

Doing your homework on insurers operating in the Naperville area will help you find a great fit. Balance cost, coverage, and provider reputation to select the best insurance companies in Naperville for your needs.

Top Personal Injury Lawyers Naperville, IL/6 Secrets of the Insurance Companies/The Collins Law Firm


Who is the most trusted insurance company?

Insurance company
Best for
Bankrate Score
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best for military-focused coverage
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Best for added perks
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5

What does the Illinois Department of Insurance do?

To protect consumers by providing assistance and information, by efficiently regulating the insurance industry’s market behavior and financial solvency, and by fostering a competitive insurance marketplace.

How many insurance agencies are in Illinois?

With 1135 independent agencies in Illinois, rest assured our recommended agents offer you more options, better value and they’re local.

Leave a Comment