The Top Insurance Companies in Jeffersonville, Indiana

Jeffersonville, Indiana is home to a variety of insurance companies that provide coverage options for residents and businesses in the area. Finding the right insurance company in Jeffersonville can seem overwhelming, but knowing the top options available can help simplify the process. This article will provide an overview of the leading insurance carriers in Jeffersonville and what they offer locally.

Types of Insurance Available in Jeffersonville

Jeffersonville residents and businesses can access all the major types of insurance from local agents and companies in the city. Here are some of the common insurance policies available:

• Auto Insurance – Covers liability, collisions, comprehensive damage, uninsured motorists, rental reimbursement and more. Required in Indiana.

• Homeowners Insurance – Covers the structure, possessions and liability risks for homes. Usually required by mortgage lenders.

• Renters Insurance – Similar to homeowners but for renters. Protects possessions and liability.

• Condo/Townhome Insurance – Specialized homeowners insurance for shared buildings.

• Flood Insurance – Covers flooding damages not included in homeowners or renters policies. Required in high-risk flood zones.

• Life Insurance – Provides income replacement or funeral expenses upon death. Types include term, whole, universal and variable life.

• Health Insurance – Major medical insurance to cover medical care costs and prescription drugs.

• Disability Insurance – Replaces income if injury or illness prevents working.

• Business Insurance – Broad category including general liability, commercial property, workers comp, E&O and more.

This list covers the major personal and commercial policy types, but specialized coverage like classic car insurance, equine or farm insurance are also available from Jeffersonville insurance companies.

Top Insurance Companies in Jeffersonville, Indiana

The leading insurance providers in Jeffersonville offer options from national, regional and local insurers. Here are some of the top insurance companies available to Jeffersonville residents and businesses:

State Farm

• Overview: National company and #1 home and auto insurer in the U.S. Full range of personal and commercial policies.

• Contact: Rachel Bonewit, Agent. 502 Missouri Ave, Jeffersonville, IN 47130. (812) 288-3399

Allstate

• Overview: Well-known national insurer for auto, home, life, retirement, and business insurance.

• Contact: Jeremy Page, Agent. 104 Commerce Dr, Jeffersonville, IN 47130. (812) 288-8660

American Family Insurance

• Overview: Regional auto, homeowners, business, farm and life insurance. Based in Madison, WI.

• Contact: Greg Meyer, Agent. 2730 Ivy Tech Dr, Sellersburg, IN 47172. (812) 280-1007

Shelter Insurance

• Overview: Regional provider of auto, home, life, business insurance based in Columbia, MO.

• Contact: David Wilhoit, Agent. 103 Commerce Dr, Jeffersonville, IN 47130. (812) 288-6611

GEICO

• Overview: National auto insurer also offering homeowners, renters, condo, and motorcycle insurance.

• Contact: Local agent services not available. Purchase online or by phone.

Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

• Overview: Auto, home, life, business farm and specialty insurance. Largest farm insurer in Indiana.

• Contact: Multiple local agents available in the Jeffersonville area.

Diversified Insurance Group

• Overview: Regional insurance agency offering auto, home, life, health, business and specialty insurance. Based in Sellersburg.

• Contact: 1602 E 8th St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130. (812) 283-3500

This list covers some of the most significant insurance companies with local availability in Jeffersonville, but national companies like Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide also offer policies. Local independent agencies also provide additional insurer options.

What to Look for in a Jeffersonville Insurance Company

Choosing the right insurance company in Jeffersonville depends on your specific needs, but there are a few key factors to consider as you evaluate options:

• Coverage Offered – Make sure the insurer provides the policies you require. Review exclusions carefully.

• Price – Compare premium estimates across multiple companies. Cheaper doesn’t always mean better coverage though.

• Customer Service – Look for responsive and helpful insurers that will be there when you need to file a claim.

• Ratings – Choose established insurers with strong financial strength ratings from agencies like A.M. Best.

• Discounts – Take advantage of discounts for bundling, paying annually, good driving record, security systems and more. Ask your agent what’s available.

Doing your homework by getting quotes from different agencies and looking up ratings and reviews for insurance companies can help you find the right provider for your situation. For a more personalized recommendation, try working with a local independent insurance agent who can compare multiple companies on your behalf.

Top Local Insurance Agencies in Jeffersonville

In addition to national and regional insurance carriers, Jeffersonville residents and businesses have access to great independent insurance agencies. These local agencies offer insurance from a variety of companies, allowing them to shop around and find you the best fit based on your needs.

Here are some of the top local insurance agencies in Jeffersonville:

Diversified Insurance Group

• Offers auto, home, business, life, health and specialty insurance
• Over 150 years combined staff experience
• Local and nationally recognized insurance companies
• Free quotes
• Address: 1602 E 8th St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
• Phone: (812) 283-3500

Schiller Insurance Agency

• Provides auto, home, business, health, life and disability insurance
• Family owned agency since 1960
• Represents over two dozen insurance carriers
• Address: 104 E Maple St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
• Phone: (812) 283-2205

The Scheller Agency

• Sells insurance coverage for home, auto, flood, business, farm and more
• Independent family-run agency since 1920
• Prompt local claims handling
• Address: 116 E Court Ave, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
• Phone: (812) 283-6683

Gibson Insurance

• Offers customized packages for home, auto, business and speciality insurance
• Trusted Jeffersonville insurance advisors for over 55 years
• Free quotes and same day coverage
• Address: 3210 Middle Rd, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
• Phone: (812) 283-3551

Surety Insurance Group

• Provides business, home, auto, health, life and disability insurance
• Represents over 15 national and regional insurance carriers
• Specializes in contractor bonds and commercial trucking insurance
• Address: 320 Missouri Ave, Jeffersonville, IN 47130
• Phone: (812) 288-4400

These agencies have deep roots in Jeffersonville and Southern Indiana and have experience finding coverage for all sorts of individuals and business insurance needs. Their access to multiple carriers allows custom quoting to get clients the right policy at a competitive price.

Key Takeaways on Jeffersonville Insurance Companies

• Jeffersonville, Indiana residents have access to insurance from top national, regional and local providers.

• Auto, homeowners, business and life insurance policies are readily available from Jeffersonville insurance companies and agencies. Specialty policies can be secured as needed.

• Look for insurers with strong financial ratings, good customer service reputations and the ability to offer you required discounts.

• Work with a local independent insurance agency to have an advocate who can compare multiple companies to find your perfect match based on coverage and price.

• Leading options for Jeffersonville insurance agencies include Diversified Insurance Group, Schiller Insurance Agency and The Scheller Agency.

Finding the right insurance does not have to be a hassle. By understanding the Jeffersonville insurance market and working with reputable local insurance professionals, you can secure the coverage you need to properly protect your assets and peace of mind.