Finding the Best Independent Insurance Agents in Columbus, Ohio

Purchasing insurance can be confusing, with many options to weigh regarding coverage, cost, and insurer reputation. Working with an independent insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio can simplify the process. They shop multiple companies to find you the right policy at a competitive price.

This guide will explain the benefits of using an independent agent for home, auto, business, life and other insurance needs. We’ll also showcase top highly rated independent agencies in Columbus and provide tips for choosing the right one for you.

What is an Independent Insurance Agent?

An independent insurance agent is a licensed professional who offers insurance policies from a variety of different companies. They are not employed by any single carrier. This allows them to provide unbiased recommendations on the best coverage options for each client’s unique needs and budget.

Independent agents act as your advocate. They shop the market and negotiate with insurers on your behalf to secure optimal pricing and contract terms. You get personalized service combined with the leverage of an intermediary representing your interests.

Benefits of working with independent insurance agents include:

  • Broader policy selection – Access to quotes from numerous insurers all in one place. An independent agent may represent up to 20 carriers.

  • Customized packages – Mix and match home, auto, business, life etc. policies across different companies for maximum savings.

  • Local expertise – Established independents understand the Columbus insurance market and local risk factors.

  • Trusted advisors – Ongoing support as your needs change. An independent agent acts as a trusted risk management partner.

  • Claims assistance – Help resolving claim disputes and accessing insurer resources quickly.

  • Time savings – Avoid shopping multiple carriers on your own. Independents do the legwork for you.

Whether you need a standard auto policy or more complex commercial insurance coverage, an experienced independent insurance agent simplifies the process while getting you optimal rates.

Top Independent Insurance Agencies in Columbus, Ohio

Columbus hosts dozens of independent insurance agencies with proven track records helping both individuals and businesses. Among the highest rated are:

Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency

  • Services: Business, home, auto, life
  • Google Rating: 4.9 from 180+ reviews
  • BBB Rating: A+, Accredited Business
  • Sample Review: “They found us the perfect insurance plan that was also cost-effective. The team is friendly, responsive and easy to work with.”

With 80+ years serving Columbus, Thomas-Fenner-Woods provides customized insurance packages and risk management guidance supported by strong carrier relationships.

W.E. Davis Insurance Agency

  • Services: Home, auto, business, life
  • Google Rating: 4.9 from 90+ reviews
  • BBB Rating: A+, Accredited Business
  • Sample Review: “Davis Insurance was able to bundle our home and auto policies together saving us 23% off our premiums. Great service!”

W.E. Davis is a family-owned agency with 60+ years experience. They leverage relationships with national and regional carriers to optimize pricing.

K&M Insurance Agency

  • Services: Business, home, auto, bonds
  • Google Rating: 4.8 from 250+ reviews
  • BBB Rating: A+ rating
  • Sample Review: “Helped us customize commercial insurance specific to our small business’ risks. Highly professional.”

K&M Insurance provides customized packages for both individuals and Columbus businesses. As an independent agency, they objectively assess needs to identify optimal solutions.

Horizon Insurance Services

  • Services: Home, auto, business, life
  • Google Rating: 4.8 from 70+ reviews
  • BBB Rating: A+ Accredited Business
  • Sample Review: “Found me great rates on home and auto insurance. Very friendly and answered all my questions.”

Horizon Insurance offers personalized service and insurance education so Columbus consumers can make informed decisions. They offer quotes from top regional and national carriers.

Soller Insurance Agency

  • Services: Business, home, auto
  • Google Rating: 4.8 from 180+ reviews
  • BBB Rating: A+ Accredited Business
  • Sample Review: “Had a great experience getting business insurance through Soller. Highly recommend!”

Trusted since 1946, Soller Insurance provides Columbus auto owners and businesses with optimal coverage options across 20+ top insurers.

How to Choose the Right Independent Insurance Agency

Choosing an independent insurance agent involves more than just looking for the lowest rates. Consider these factors to find an agency that fits your needs:

  • Years in business – Look for an established agency with 10+ years experience in Columbus. This indicates solid relationships with insurers.

  • Range of carriers – Do they partner with companies you know and trust? Top independents represent 10-20 A-rated insurers.

  • Online reviews – Check Google and BBB ratings. Look for consistent 5 star reviews praising great service.

  • Offerings match needs – An agency specializing in home policies may not be the right fit for commercial accounts.

  • Service capabilities – How accessible are the agents if you have questions? Do they provide guidance on insurance optimization as your needs evolve?

  • Location – While not essential, picking an agency nearby can make meetings and document delivery easier.

  • Personal rapport – You’ll be interacting often, so ensure the agent seems trustworthy and makes you feel at ease.

Reaching out for quotes from a few top independents gives you options to find just the right agency match. Leverage their expertise to secure optimal Columbus insurance coverage.

Ohio Insurance Agents Association CEO’s message to independent agents


What is the advantage of using an independent insurance agent?

Independent agents are, therefore, able to sell insurance policies from multiple companies, where they are paid on commission for each policy sold. It is often beneficial for a customer to work with an independent agent because they may be able to quickly research multiple policies and rates across various companies.

What is the difference between an independent agent and an insurance company?

While independent agents do not have access to the support and referrals that insurance companies provide to their exclusive agents, independent insurance agents have the benefit of being able to offer their clients policies from multiple insurance providers, giving them the ability to offer a wider selection of …

What do most independent insurance agents make?

While ZipRecruiter is seeing annual salaries as high as $139,500 and as low as $27,500, the majority of Independent Insurance Sales Agent salaries currently range between $47,500 (25th percentile) to $89,500 (75th percentile) with top earners (90th percentile) making $125,000 annually across the United States.

What is independent insurance agency?

Independent insurance agencies are separate from the insurance companies they represent, allowing them to offer insurance from more than one company and select the policies that best meet their customers’ needs.

Leave a Comment