Finding Affordable Car Insurance for 23-Year-Old Drivers

Turning 23 is an exciting time in life. You have more independence and freedom. But along with that often comes high car insurance costs, especially for male drivers. This article explores how 23-year-olds can find cheap car insurance through smart shopping, policy customization, discounts, and safe driving.

Why Rates Are High for 23-Year-Olds

Insurance companies classify 23-year-olds as relatively high-risk drivers based on statistical accident data. Some key reasons rates are higher include:

  • Lack of experience – Drivers get better with experience. With less time behind the wheel, rates are higher.

  • Risk-taking behavior – Data shows younger drivers speed, tailgate, text while driving, and drive under the influence at higher rates. This raises the risk of accidents.

  • High performance vehicles – Younger drivers are more likely to drive high-powered sports cars that are costly to insure.

  • Gender – Statistically males under 25 have a higher accident rate than females. This is reflected in higher premiums.

  • Single status – Unmarried young drivers pay more than those who are married. Married people tend to drive more carefully.

  • Urban environment – Insurance costs more in urban areas due to higher accident rates, vandalism, and theft. Many 23-year-olds live in cities.

While these risk factors lead to higher base rates, there are many ways to reduce car insurance costs for 23-year-olds.

Shop Multiple Insurers for Quotes

The best way to find the cheapest car insurance at age 23 is to get multiple quotes. Rates can vary dramatically between different insurance companies for the same driver.

Here are some of the top insurers that tend to offer competitive rates for young drivers:

  • Geico
  • Progressive
  • State Farm
  • Allstate
  • Esurance
  • Liberty Mutual
  • The Hartford
  • Travelers
  • Nationwide

Be sure to get quotes from both national carriers and local insurance providers. Local insurers that operate in just one state can sometimes offer lower premiums.

Online quote comparison sites like make this process easy by letting you get quotes from multiple companies at once. This saves time instead of contacting each insurer individually.

Consider Usage-Based Programs

Many insurers now offer usage-based or telematics programs that use an app or device to monitor actual driving habits. These programs track metrics like speed, acceleration, braking, turning, mileage, and time of driving. The collected data is used to calculate premium discounts based on how safely you drive.

For a 23-year-old, using one of these programs can lead to significant savings compared to traditional rates. Insurers like Progressive, State Farm, and Allstate all offer usage-based options. However, they do involve installing a tracking device in your vehicle or using a mobile app to monitor drives.

Adjust Deductibles to Lower Costs

Selecting higher deductibles can substantially reduce monthly premiums. For example, increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 could lower your rate by 15% or more. Just be sure you have funds available to pay the higher deductible if you need to file a claim.

Also consider dropping optional coverages like rental reimbursement or roadside assistance if money is tight. While this limits your protection, it can make the policy more affordable.

Take Advantage of Discounts

Most insurers provide discounts to help offset high rates for younger drivers. Be sure to ask about discounts you may qualify for:

  • Good student discount – For maintaining a B or better grade point average.
  • Defensive driver – For completing an approved defensive driving course.
  • Multi-policy – Bundling auto with renters or homeowners insurance.
  • Multi-car – Insuring more than one vehicle on the same policy.
  • Paid in full – Pay annual premium upfront rather than monthly.
  • Safety features – For cars with airbags, antilock brakes, alarm system, etc.

The more discounts you can stack together, the more you will save. Even small discounts of 5-15% add up quickly.

Pick a Safe, Reliable Car

The vehicle you drive is a major rating factor for insurance companies. Sporty cars, luxury models, and vehicles with high horsepower get hit with much higher insurance premiums due to repair costs, accident rates, and theft appeal.

Instead, choose an economy or mid-size sedan from a brand known for safety and reliability, such as:

  • Toyota Camry
  • Honda Accord
  • Nissan Altima
  • Ford Fusion
  • Chevrolet Malibu
  • Subaru Legacy

Newer model years with the latest safety equipment score better as well. Avoid any vehicle modifications, which increase insurance costs.

Maintain a Clean Driving Record

The absolute best way for a 23-year-old to get lower car insurance rates is to drive safely and avoid moving violations and at-fault accidents. Just one ticket or accident can inflate rates tremendously.

  • Drive defensively
  • Obey speed limits
  • Allow large following distance
  • Avoid distractions like cell phones

Also avoid filing small claims that end up on your record as ‘accidents.’ Pay out-of-pocket for small scratches or dents to keep your record clean.

Consider Pay-Per-Mile Insurance

Pay-per-mile or usage-based insurance (UBI) charges premiums based on how many miles you actually drive during the policy term. This can greatly benefit drivers with low annual mileage like students, city dwellers, or those who use public transportation.

With traditional policies, insurance companies estimate your driving mileage. But with pay-per-mile insurance, the premium is customized precisely to how much you drive. Metromile and Milewise are two leading pay-per-mile insurance providers.

Increase Liability Coverage Limits

Carrying just the minimum required liability coverage is a mistake for drivers of any age. If you cause an at-fault accident, minimum limits may not cover the claim, leaving you on the hook for thousands.

Instead, consider increasing liability limits to:

  • $100,000/$300,000 bodily injury per person/accident
  • $50,000 property damage liability

The extra premium cost is small compared to the additional protection gained. Higher liability limits also demonstrate financial responsibility, helping you earn a discount.

Explore Non-Owners Insurance

If you only drive borrowed, rented, or shared vehicles occasionally, non-owners insurance can provide affordable liability protection. It covers damages to others when driving a non-owned car.

Non-owners policies only cost a few hundred dollars per year. But they give peace of mind that you have coverage when running errands in a parents’ car, driving for Uber or Lyft, renting a moving truck, or borrowing a friend’s vehicle.

Check Rates Again Once Turning 25

Remember that insurance rates decrease quickly for drivers as they enter their mid-twenties. So even if you have to pay higher premiums now, you will see substantial savings after turning 25 if you maintain a clean record.

Be sure to re-shop rates from multiple companies around your 25th birthday. Loyalty rarely pays off, so don’t hesitate to switch insurers to get the best rate.


It’s normal for 23-year-olds to face expensive auto insurance premiums. But following the strategies in this guide can help young drivers find affordable rates through smart shopping, policy customization, maximizing discounts, choosing the right car, and driving safely. Maintaining spotless driving record is also key tolower costs.

With some diligent research and defensive driving habits, 23-year-olds can find substantially cheaper car insurance. Review rates annually and shop insurers again at age 25 to maximize savings. Careful driving and responsible decisions will be rewarded with better insurance rates over time.

The Cheapest Car Insurance in 2023


What’s the cheapest insurance for a 23-year-old?

Erie has the cheapest full coverage car insurance for 23-year-olds, at $155 per month. Erie offers rates that are 17% cheaper than an average insurer. Geico is the cheapest car insurance company for 23-year-olds that is available nationwide, at $208 per month.

Will my insurance go down when I turn 23?

While your auto insurance rates may drop at age 25, they will go down the most when you turn 19 (a 16% savings) and when you turn 21 (a 17% drop). The reason car insurance is expensive for drivers under age 25 is because younger drivers are statistically more likely to get into an accident than older drivers.

What age group has the cheapest car insurance?

Experienced drivers are less likely to have accident claims, which means they cost less to insure. At Progressive, the average premium per driver tends to decrease significantly from 19-34 and then stabilize or decrease slightly from 34-75.

Who typically has the cheapest insurance?

State Farm is the cheapest car insurance company overall according to NerdWallet’s analysis, with an average rate of $39 a month for minimum coverage. It was also the cheapest in our analysis of cheap full coverage auto insurance.

Leave a Comment