The Top Insurance Companies in Sumter, SC

Sumter, South Carolina is home to over 40,000 residents who rely on insurance to protect their assets. With so many options, choosing the right insurance company in Sumter can be overwhelming. This article will explore the top insurance companies servicing Sumter, SC to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of Major Insurance Companies in Sumter

Here is a brief overview of the major insurance companies available to Sumter residents:

  • Nationwide – Nationwide is one of the largest insurance and financial services companies in the world, providing auto, home, life, business and specialty insurance. They have multiple local agents in the Sumter area.

  • Travelers – The Travelers Companies, Inc is a leading provider of property and casualty insurance. They offer home, auto, business and renters insurance through local independent agencies.

  • State Farm – State Farm is the largest property and casualty insurance provider in the United States. They offer a wide variety of insurance and financial products.

  • Allstate – Allstate is one of the largest publicly held insurance companies, providing auto, home, renters, motorcycle, life and business insurance.

  • Progressive – Progressive is known for auto insurance but also provides homeowners, motorcycle, boat, commercial auto and other insurance products.

  • Liberty Mutual – Liberty Mutual offers automobile, home, life, business and specialty insurance. They have an extensive network of local agents.

  • USAA – USAA provides insurance, banking and investment services to current and former military members and their families.

Now let’s take a deeper look at some of the factors to consider when choosing insurance in Sumter.

Key Factors to Consider

When selecting an insurance company in Sumter, here are some of the key factors to consider:

Reputation & Financial Strength

You want an established company with a solid reputation that will be there when you need them. Review financial strength ratings from independent agencies like A.M. Best when comparing insurers.

Local Agents & Service

Having knowledgeable local agents and quality customer service can make or break your insurance experience. Evaluate accessibility, responsiveness and expertise.

Coverages & Discounts Offered

The company you choose should offer the coverages you need at competitive rates. Look for available discounts like bundling policies, safety features, good driving record, etc.

Customer Satisfaction

Check customer reviews and complaints ratios. How the company handles claims is crucial – do they have a history of fair settlements?


Compare quotes from multiple insurers carefully, taking into account coverage amounts, limitations and deductibles. Don’t focus only on the lowest premium.

Getting quotes from some of the major insurance providers in Sumter can help you evaluate these factors.

Quotes from Top Providers in Sumter

To give you a better idea of what’s available, here are sample quotes a 40 year old driver might receive for basic full-coverage car insurance from some of the top companies in Sumter, SC:

Company Sample Annual Quote
State Farm $1,678
Nationwide $1,542
Allstate $1,933
Progressive $$1,284
Travelers $1,416

And sample homeowners insurance quotes for $250,000 in dwelling coverage and $100,000 in personal liability coverage:

Company Sample Annual Quote
Travelers $1,680
State Farm $1,248
Nationwide $1,540
Allstate $1,935
Liberty Mutual $2,100

While price is a major factor, remember to look at the big picture including reputation, service and coverages offered when selecting an insurance provider in Sumter.

Top Insurance Companies in Sumter Reviewed

Now let’s take a more in-depth look at some of the top insurance companies available to Sumter residents:


  • Overview – Nationwide is one of the largest insurance and financial services companies in the world. They market products through independent agents as well as directly to consumers.

  • Pros – Excellent financial strength (A+ from A.M. Best), good customer service reputation, large variety of policies available including specialty lines. Local agents provide personalized service.

  • Cons – Customer satisfaction ratings not as high as some competitors. Some complaints about claims handling.

  • Best For – Customers who value having a local agent and a wide range of insurance/financial products.

  • Number of Local Agents – Nationwide has at least 5 agency locations in the greater Sumter area.


  • Overview – The Travelers Companies, Inc. is one of the largest property and casualty insurers, selling through independent agents under the Travelers brand.

  • Pros – Strong financial ratings (A++ from A.M. Best). Good customer service reputation and claims satisfaction. Offers coverage for classic cars and weddings/events.

  • Cons – Limited online tools and support. Higher premiums than some competitors.

  • Best For – Customers who prefer working through independent agents and value claim satisfaction.

  • Number of Local Agents – Over 5 independent agencies represent Travelers in Sumter.

State Farm

  • Overview – State Farm is the #1 home and auto insurer in the U.S. They sell insurance policies exclusively through local agent offices.

  • Pros – Excellent financial strength (A++ from A.M. Best) and high marks for claims handling. Local agents provide very personalized service. Many discounts available.

  • Cons – Restrictive underwriting guidelines, more limited coverage options than some competitors. Mixed reviews for customer service.

  • Best For – Customers who value face-to-face service through a local agent and simple policies.

  • Number of Local Agents – State Farm has at least 10 agent offices in the Sumter area.


  • Overview – Allstate is one of the largest publicly held P&C insurance companies, selling through exclusive agents as well as directly to consumers.

  • Pros – Strong financial ratings (A+ from A.M. Best). Excellent claims satisfaction and customer service reviews. Offers accident forgiveness and safe driving bonuses.

  • Cons – Limited package discounts compared to some competitors. Some complaints about underwriting and premium increases.

  • Best For – Motorists who want award-winning claims service and don’t mind paying a little more for it.

  • Number of Local Agents – At least 5 dedicated Allstate agencies operate in Sumter.


  • Overview – Progressive is the #3 auto insurer in the U.S., focusing mainly on auto policies but also offering other insurance like homeowners and commercial.

  • Pros – Competitive rates and numerous discounts available such as for safe drivers, anti-theft devices and paying in full. Excellent online quotes and tools.

  • Cons – Less personalized service with no local agents. Some complaints about claims handling.

  • Best For – Budget-conscious consumers who are comfortable managing policies online vs. through an agent.

  • Number of Local Agents – Progressive operates in Sumter but does not have local agent offices. Policies are sold online/directly.

Finding the Best Insurance in Sumter, SC

When choosing insurance coverage, you want to find the right balance of cost, financial stability, service and features. Here are some final tips for picking insurance in Sumter:

  • Compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate for your situation. Be sure to evaluate coverages not just premium price.

  • Check companies’ financial strength ratings and customer satisfaction scores. Strong financials and positive reviews are good signs.

  • If having a local agent is important, look for companies like State Farm and Nationwide with multiple agent offices in Sumter.

  • Ask friends and family members for insurance provider recommendations based on their local experience.

  • Review policy options like bundling home and auto for multi-policy discounts. Consider add-ons like accident forgiveness too.

  • Work with agents or company reps to clarify coverages and exclusions before purchasing a policy. Ask questions!

By taking the time to shop around and compare insurers, Sumter residents can find the right insurance provider to protect their vehicles, homes and other assets at the best rate. Do your research to ensure you select a financially stable company that offers the services and coverages you need.

The 5 BEST Auto Insurance Companies


How much is insurance per month in South Carolina?

South Carolina drivers pay 19% more for full-coverage car insurance than the average American driver. Overall, South Carolina drivers pay an average of $291 per month for full-coverage insurance and $167 per month for liability-only coverage.

What is the minimum insurance coverage in South Carolina?

What auto insurance coverage is required in SC? Answer: Drivers are required to carry liability and uninsured motorist coverage with the following limits: $25,000 Bodily Injury Per Person / $50,000 Bodily Injury Per Accident / $25,000 Property Damage Per Accident.

What are the cheapest big insurance companies?

Average cost per year for good drivers
Average cost per month for good drivers

Leave a Comment