Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Fresno, CA

Fresno is the fifth largest city in California and home to almost 500,000 residents. With a bustling economy and diverse population, Fresno has insurance needs spanning auto, home, business, life, and more. The city is served by dozens of national, regional and local insurance companies competing for customers. This article explores the best insurance companies in Fresno, CA based on financial strength, customer satisfaction, coverage options and affordability.

How We Evaluated Fresno’s Insurance Companies

To identify the top insurance providers in Fresno, we used these key criteria:

  • Financial strength – Insurers with higher financial strength ratings are more likely to pay out claims. We looked at AM Best and other agency ratings.

  • Customer service – Companies with higher marks for customer satisfaction provide better service. We considered JD Power, BBB and other review site ratings.

  • Coverage options – The best insurers offer a wide range of tailored insurance policies to meet local needs.

  • Affordability – We compared quotes for similar policies to find insurers with competitive pricing.

  • Digital experience – Ease of managing your policy and filing claims online were also considered.

Based on these metrics, below are the best insurance companies in Fresno in key categories:

Best Insurance Companies in Fresno

Auto Insurance

Mercury Insurance – As California’s 3rd largest insurer, Mercury offers affordable auto insurance rates along with convenient local agents throughout Fresno. They have an A rating from AM Best.

State Farm – Known for strong customer service, State Farm offers Fresno drivers extensive agent assistance plus discounts like multi-policy, safe driver, and good student. They have an AM Best rating of A++.

Geico – Geico is praised for low cost auto insurance paired with an easy online quote and policy management experience through their app. They have an AM Best rating of A++.

Home Insurance

State Farm – Topping home insurance rankings in Fresno, State Farm agents provide localized expertise while bundling home and auto policies can save you up to 25%. State Farm has an AM Best rating of A++.

Allstate – Allstate insures thousands of Fresno homeowners with options like replacement cost coverage for personal belongings and mold remediation. Their AM Best rating is A+.

Farmers Insurance – Known for discounts like smart home device and claim-free, Farmers provides home coverage tailored for Fresno residents. They have an AM Best rating of A.

Business Insurance

The Hartford – Offering Fresno businesses plans like BOP, commercial auto, and professional liability, The Hartford has an AM Best rating of A+ and provides flexible coverage.

State Farm – From food trucks to startups, State Farm agents in Fresno offer customized business insurance policies backed by unbeatable financial strength (AM Best A++).

Nationwide – Nationwide’s business insurance plans bundle general liability, property, auto, workers’ comp, and more. They have an AM Best rating of A+ and local Fresno agents.

Health Insurance

Blue Shield of California – The largest health insurer based in the state, Blue Shield provides access to quality doctors through HMO, PPO and POS plans. Their AM Best rating is A.

Kaiser Permanente – Kaiser offers restricted HMO network plans with focus on preventive care and coordinated treatment. They have an AM Best rating of A.

Anthem Blue Cross – Anthem provides Fresno residents PPO, HMO and retirement health plans. They have an AM Best rating of A- and cover 1 in 8 Californians.

Life Insurance

Banner Life – Specializing in term life insurance, Banner Life is known for quick and easy online quotes/approvals. Though not rated by AM Best, they have strong financials.

New York Life – The largest mutual life insurer, New York Life provides permanent life policies with lifetime coverage. They have the highest AM Best rating of A++.

Pacific Life – Pacific Life offers Fresno customers permanent and term life insurance, annuities, investments and more. They have an AM Best rating of A+.

Tips for Finding the Right Insurer in Fresno

While the companies above give you a starting point, here are a few additional tips on finding the best insurance providers:

  • Shop around – Get quotes from at least 3 insurers before deciding for the best rates.

  • Compare coverage – Look beyond price to make sure each company’s policies match your specific risks.

  • Examine ratings – Only consider insurers rated “A” or higher by agencies like AM Best for financial security.

  • Ask about discounts – Inquire what discounts each insurer offers that may apply to you.

  • Read reviews – Feedback from current policyholders provides insight into customer service.

  • Interview agents – For complicated policies, an independent insurance agent may compare multiple insurers on your behalf.

Doing your due diligence lets you find great coverage at the best price point from insurers equipped to handle Fresno claims. Comparing top-rated companies keeps your home, car, health and business protected.

Overview of the Fresno Insurance Marketplace

To understand the local insurance landscape better, here is an overview of key categories:

Auto Insurance

  • Minimum liability limits are 15/30/5 in California
  • Average annual premium in Fresno is $1,668, 7% lower than state average
  • Top auto insurers by market share: State Farm, GEICO, Mercury

Homeowners Insurance

  • Average annual premium is $1,194, 43% higher than national average
  • Nearly half of local housing units were built before 1970
  • Top insurers: State Farm, Allstate, Farmers

Health Insurance

  • 7.5% of Fresno residents are uninsured
  • 60% are covered by employer-sponsored plans
  • Top insurers: Blue Shield, Kaiser Permanente, Anthem Blue Cross

Business Insurance

  • Over 43,000 small businesses operating in the city
  • Agriculture and food processing are major local industries
  • Top insurers: The Hartford, State Farm, Nationwide

Life Insurance

  • Average policy face amount is $171,000 in the state
  • Over 2.2 million individual life policies active in California
  • Leading life insurers: New York Life, State Farm, Northwestern Mutual

Finding the Best Rates with Top Insurers

Fresno residents can secure coverage through highly-rated national and regional insurance companies offering competitive rates. Getting quotes from the insurers recommended above makes it easy to compare pricing.

However, community-focused local insurance agents are also worth speaking to. The best local agents have access to quotes from regional and national companies. They can compare rates on your behalf and match you with the insurer offering the optimal mix of coverage, price, and service.

Work with reputable insurance professionals to find the right policy at the best price to protect your cars, home, health, family, and business in Fresno.

Car Insurance Fresno Ca |


What is the cheapest car insurance in California?

According to our cost research, Geico provides the cheapest minimum liability insurance in California, costing $33 per month or $398 per year on average. USAA, Progressive, CSAA Insurance and Mercury Insurance are also affordable insurance options.

Who is the most trusted insurance company?

Insurance company
Best for
Bankrate Score
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best for military-focused coverage
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Best for added perks
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5

How much is the car insurance in Fresno California?

Our data shows a minimum coverage auto insurance policy in Fresno, Calif., costs $47 per month or $569 per year on average. If you want full coverage, you’ll pay an average of $183 per month or $2,197 per year.

Leave a Comment