Finding the Best Insurance Companies in Fort Lauderdale, FL

Fort Lauderdale is a major city in South Florida and popular tourist destination. With its beaches, boating culture, and tropical climate, Fort Lauderdale attracts over 12 million visitors per year.

As a growing metropolitan area, Fort Lauderdale is also home to many residents and businesses seeking protection through insurance. From home and auto insurance to commercial policies, having proper coverage is crucial in this exposed coastal region.

But with so many insurance options, how do you identify the best companies for your needs in Fort Lauderdale? This comprehensive guide examines major insurers in the area, reviews, financial ratings, customer service, and more to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of Major Insurance Companies in Fort Lauderdale

The Fort Lauderdale insurance market features national insurers, regional providers, and local agencies. Here is a overview of major companies offering home, auto, life, business, and specialty insurance in Fort Lauderdale and across Florida:

State Farm – National company and #1 insurer in Florida. Offers auto, home, life, health, and business insurance.

Geico – National direct insurer known for auto insurance. Also provides homeowners, renters, and umbrella policies.

Progressive – Major national insurer with competitive rates for auto, motorcycle, homeowners, and renters insurance.

Allstate – Offers auto, homeowners, renters, and life insurance policies nationwide and in Florida.

Citizens Property Insurance – State-run insurer providing home, condo, and renters insurance to Florida residents.

Florida Peninsula Insurance – Regional property insurer serving homeowners across Florida.

People’s Trust – Florida-based insurer specializing in home insurance for high-risk areas.

This list includes some of the largest and most prominent insurance companies in Fort Lauderdale. Many national insurers operate local agents and offices throughout the city. There are also smaller regional and local agencies to consider.

Insurance Company Financial Strength & Ratings

When choosing an insurance provider, you want to ensure the company is financially stable and able to pay out future claims. Independent rating agencies assess each insurer’s financial situation.

Here are the current ratings for major Fort Lauderdale insurance companies:

  • State Farm – S&P: AA+ (Strong), A.M. Best: A++ (Superior)

  • Geico – S&P: A++ (Extremely Strong), A.M. Best: A++ (Superior)

  • Progressive – S&P: A+ (Strong), A.M. Best: A+ (Superior)

  • Allstate – S&P: A+ (Strong), A.M. Best: A+ (Superior)

  • Citizens – Demotech: A (Exceptional)

  • Florida Peninsula – Demotech: A (Exceptional)

  • People’s Trust – Demotech: A (Exceptional)

Most major insurers in Fort Lauderdale hold strong “A” ratings from agencies like A.M. Best, S&P, and Demotech. These indicate very good to excellent financial standing. Citizens and regional companies may rely more on Demotech ratings.

Overall, the major insurance providers operating in Fort Lauderdale appear to be financially stable choices able to pay out claims. However, you still want to compare ratings between your short list of options.

Customer Service Reputation of Fort Lauderdale Insurers

In addition to financial strength, customer service and satisfaction are important when picking an insurance company. How do the major insurers serving Fort Lauderdale rate when it comes to service quality and claims experiences?

Here are excerpts of customer feedback from online reviews:

State Farm:

“My agent has always been so helpful when I’ve had to file claims on my home and cars with State Farm.”

“Customer service is hit or miss. The local agent is good but getting a hold of corporate claims department can be frustrating.”


“I’ve never had to file a claim with Geico, but anytime I call with questions their reps are friendly and solve issues quickly.”

“Geico made the process easy when I had to file a claim after a minor accident. My car was repaired and back on the road fast.”


“The rates are affordable but customer service is severely lacking. I often get bounced around departments calling about my policy.”

“Progressive’s claims process was seamless start to finish when a tree fell and damaged my roof last storm season.”


“Allstate provides great customer service both from my local agent and their claims department.”

“The adjusters seemed more focused on denying my claim than helping me recover from storm damage.”

Service quality can vary between different customers. Overall, State Farm and Geico have strong customer satisfaction ratings in Fort Lauderdale. Experiences with Progressive and Allstate are more mixed. But your own experience may differ.

Average Insurance Rates in Fort Lauderdale

Cost often drives insurance buying decisions. Here are average annual premium estimates for common policies in Fort Lauderdale:

  • Auto Insurance – $1,500 per year

  • Homeowners Insurance – $2,500 per year

  • Renters Insurance – $200 per year

  • Term Life Insurance (30 year old) – $150 per year

  • Business Insurance – $1,000 per year

Rates will be personalized based on your specific circumstances like age, driving record, policy limits, property details, and more. Be sure to obtain customized quotes from multiple companies before deciding.

Top 5 Insurance Companies in Fort Lauderdale

Taking into account financial strength, customer service, affordability, and local reputation, here are our choices for top insurance providers in Fort Lauderdale:

  1. State Farm – Overall best insurance choice in Fort Lauderdale. Offers competitive pricing and good customer experiences across auto, home, and life insurance. Their strong financial ratings provide added peace of mind.

  2. Geico – A great option if you want to buy insurance direct. Geico offers affordable auto insurance quotes and strong claims experiences. Also provides homeowners and renters policies.

  3. Florida Peninsula – Leading regional insurer providing affordable and reliable home insurance across Florida coastal markets.

  4. People’s Trust – Specializes in home insurance for high-risk hurricane zones in Florida. Competitive pricing and policy options.

  5. Progressive – Competitively priced auto and home insurance policies. Streamlined online quotes and claims processes. Just be aware of mixed customer service reviews.

This covers some of the best home, auto, and business insurance companies in Fort Lauderdale to consider. Be sure to get quotes from multiple providers before deciding on coverage.

Choosing the Right Fort Lauderdale Insurance Company For You

Finding the ideal insurance fit comes down to your specific situation and coverage priorities. Keep the following in mind when choosing providers:

  • If you want bundled policies, look to larger insurers like State Farm and Allstate that offer auto, home, and life insurance. This makes coordination more seamless.

  • Go with Geico or Progressive if low rates are your top concern. But compare a few companies, as prices can vary.

  • For home insurance in high-risk coastal areas, Florida Peninsula and People’s Trust cater to this market.

  • If you have an outstanding claim or disaster recovery scenario, choose a company known for strong customer service, like State Farm.

  • For business insurance, agents that provide personalized local service may be preferable to direct national insurers.

Take your time and compare options. Reach out to agents or get quotes online. Finding the right insurance match provides important protection, so make sure you feel comfortable with the provider.

The Bottom Line

Securing insurance tailored to your situation brings peace of mind. Fort Lauderdale has no shortage of insurance providers to choose from for home, auto, life, business, and other policies.

Leading insurers like State Farm and Geico offer competitive pricing and service. For homeowners insurance, Florida Peninsula and People’s Trust cater specifically to the coastal climate.

Do your due diligence in researching options, comparing quotes, and reading reviews. And consult insurance agents to address any questions. This ensures you find great Fort Lauderdale insurance companies to protect what matters most.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Fort Lauderdale – 30 Hours Of Research


Who has the cheapest Florida insurance?

The cheapest car insurance companies in Florida include State Farm, Geico, Travelers, Farmers and Progressive.

Who is the most trusted insurance company?

Insurance company
Best for
Bankrate Score
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best overall
4.4 Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Best for military-focused coverage
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Best for added perks
4.3 Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5

How much is car insurance in Fort Lauderdale?

The average cost of car insurance in Fort Lauderdale in 2023 is $1,152 per year for minimum liability coverage, or $96 a month; and $3,197 per year for full coverage, which works out to $266 a month.

Leave a Comment