Finding the Best Insurance Agents in Boston, MA

Boston is home to some of the top insurance agencies and agents in Massachusetts. With major insurance companies headquartered in the city and a large pool of experienced agents, Bostonians have fantastic options when it comes to finding coverage. This article provides an overview of working with insurance agents in Boston along with tips for identifying the best ones to meet your needs.

Types of Insurance Agents in Boston

There are a few main types of insurance agents active in the Boston market:

  • Independent agents: Work with multiple insurance carriers and can provide quotes from different companies to find you the best rates. Offer a wide range of policies from property to commercial.

  • Captive agents: Represent just one insurance company such as State Farm, Allstate, or AAA. Can only sell policies from that carrier but have expertise with those offerings.

  • Direct writers: Work for insurers that sell policies directly to consumers without agents as intermediaries. Offer convenience but less personalized service.

  • Brokers: Specialize in more complex risks like businesses, high net worth individuals, and specialty lines. Have expertise in niche markets and access to numerous wholesale underwriters.

Most Bostonians work with either independent or captive agents for personal insurance needs. Independent agents are popular since they can shop rates among top insurers like Liberty Mutual, Travelers, and Safety Insurance.

How Insurance Agents in Boston Get Paid

Agents earn commissions from the insurance companies when they sell policies. The commission is built into your premiums—you won’t pay any extra.

For property and casualty lines, commissions are usually 10-20% of the policy premium. For life and health insurance, commissions are more substantial since policies are longer term.

Some agents charge small service fees for things like policy changes or late payments. But otherwise, you don’t pay any direct fees when working with agents.

Do You Need an Insurance Agent in Boston?

Thanks to online quoting and policy purchase options, you can buy insurance without ever speaking to an agent. But working with a knowledgeable, reputable agent still offers significant benefits:

  • Personalized service: Agents get to know you, explain coverages, and answer questions.
  • Risk expertise: Agents have specialized product knowledge you likely don’t have.
  • Claims help: Your agent can assist with the claims process and resolve issues.
  • Ongoing policy review: Agents make sure your coverage adapts as your needs change.
  • Convenience: One agent shops multiple top insurers to find you the best fit.

The right agent looks out for your best interests for the long haul. Investing time to find one who meets your needs is worth the effort.

How to Choose the Best Insurance Agent in Boston

With Boston’s abundance of insurance agents, picking the right one takes a little research:

  • Check reviews: Online review sites like Yelp provide candid feedback from real customers about local agents.
  • Ask for referrals: Friends, family, coworkers, attorneys, and financial advisors can recommend agents they’ve had good experiences with.
  • Look for experience: Ideally, you want an established agent with extensive expertise in the types of policies you need.
  • Verify proper licensing: Agents must have a state license to sell insurance. Look up their license status with the Massachusetts Division of Insurance.
  • Consider designations: Advanced designations like CIC, CPCU, ARM, etc. show an agent’s knowledge and professionalism.
  • Evaluate customer service: Do they respond promptly to questions? Are they accessible by phone, email, and in person? Good service is crucial.
  • Compare options: Independent agents and captive agents both have pros and cons. Decide which model better matches your needs.
  • Check financial health: Make sure the agent’s agencies are financially stable organizations.

Taking these steps helps zero in on the most qualified, trustworthy insurance agents in Boston to secure the optimal coverage.

Top Insurance Agencies in Boston

Boston hosts branch locations for big national insurance brands as well as dozens of highly rated local agencies. Here are some top insurance agencies in the city:

  • Dowling & O’Neil: Full service, independent agency providing business, home, auto, and life insurance since 1921.

  • HUB International New England: Global brokerage with expertise across all lines of insurance, employee benefits, and risk management.

  • Rodman Insurance Agency: Independent, family owned agency serving Boston since 1939 with a long list of corporate and individual clients.

  • The Mahoney Group: Offers customized packages for auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.

  • Beecher Carlson: Large brokerage providing commercial and personal lines insurance, employee benefits, and retirement services.

  • Orion Insurance Group: Independent agency with strengths in condo, renters, home, and auto insurance.

  • Bonney, Bango, & Kallman: Specializes in retail, manufacturing, non-profit, and professional services clients.

  • RMS Insurance Brokerage: Focuses on catering insurance to local needs of Massachusetts residents and businesses.

Finding the Best Insurance Coverage in Boston

While a good agent is invaluable, choosing the right insurance company behind your policy is also key. Top insurers in Boston based on consumer ratings, market share, and financial strength include:

  • Auto insurance: Liberty Mutual, Safety Insurance, Arbella Insurance, Plymouth Rock, Mapfre
  • Home insurance: MAPFRE, Liberty Mutual, Safety Insurance, Chubb, Travelers
  • Renters insurance: Liberty Mutual, Travelers, Allstate, Farmers Insurance
  • Business insurance: The Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Travelers, Chubb, CNA

Discuss your coverage options with your independent agent or get quotes from captive agents to find the best carrier for your specific needs.

Popular Types of Insurance Coverage in Boston

Boston residents and businesses require coverage for:

  • Auto: Massachusetts drivers must have minimum liability limits of 20/40/5. Collision and comprehensive are recommended with high claim frequency.

  • Homeowners: Protects condos and houses from perils like fire, theft, water damage, and liability claims. Snowload and water/sewer backup coverage are important add-ons in Boston.

  • Renters: Covers personal belongings against theft, fire, and damage. About 75% of Boston residents rent.

  • Flood: Required for many Boston homes. The city averages more than 40 inches of rain per year.

  • Umbrella: Provides additional liability limits above home and auto insurance baseline coverage. Vital for high net worth individuals.

  • Business: Policies like commercial property, general liability, professional liability, workers comp, cyber insurance, and more.

Work with your Boston insurance agent to ensure you have the right policies and enough coverage.

Understanding Massachusetts Insurance Regulations

Boston insurance agents and companies must follow guidelines set by the Division of Insurance:

  • Auto insurers cannot refuse to renew policies unless very specific criteria is met.

  • Insurers must replace total loss vehicles up to 2 years old with a comparable vehicle.

  • MA has strict building code enforcement resulting in lower home insurance premiums.

  • Health plans must provide certain mandated benefits like mammograms, mental health services, and diabetes supplies.

Agents can explain how Massachusetts regulations impact your coverage. Knowing the rules allows you to maximize benefits.

How Much is Average Insurance in Boston?

Insurance costs vary quite a bit based on your risk profile. Here are some average Boston insurance premiums based on 2021 data:

  • Auto insurance: $1,168 per year
  • Home insurance: $1,520 per year
  • Renters insurance: $168 per year
  • Umbrella insurance: $150-$300 per year

Condo insurance is around 10-15% more than regular home insurance. Business insurance costs depend greatly on industry risk and revenue size. Overall, Boston insurance rates are typically higher than national averages due to factors like theft, extreme weather, high real estate costs, litigation trends, and congestion.

Key Takeaways for Finding the Best Boston Insurance Agents and Rates

The key takeaways are:

  • Independent and captive agents both provide value but with different benefits.

  • Agents earn commissions from insurers – they don’t charge you service fees.

  • Review ratings and check credentials to verify an agent’s expertise.

  • Local agencies have great expertise in Boston’s unique insurance needs.

  • Shop around with agents to compare rates from top insurers like Liberty Mutual and Travelers.

  • Understand MA insurance regulations so you get the best use of your policies.

With Boston’s extensive options for insurance agents and carriers, you can certainly find high quality coverage at competitive prices. Team up with a trusted advisor to protect your vehicles, home, business, health, and life in a city with no shortage of risks.

How to Start an Insurance Agency In 2023


Is it cheaper to buy insurance online or through an agent?

Online car insurance policies are generally cheaper than those offered by insurance agents as these don’t include commissions and other fees. Most auto insurance companies also offer discounts if you purchase car insurance online. However, using an agent has its share of benefits.

Who is the highest paid insurance agent?

Gideon du Plessis failed in the 10th standard and never went to college. He is today the highest earning insurance agent in the world, with annual commissions amounting to Rs 7 crore (Rs 70 million) plus.

What is the difference between an insurance agent and an insurance representative?

Insurance agents and insurance brokers can both help you buy an insurance policy. But insurance agents represent the insurance provider that employs them and help sell policies from that single provider. Insurance brokers represent the consumers who use them and can help them shop for policies from multiple providers.

What is the difference between insurance advisor and agent?

An Insurance Agent works for a company and thus represents it. However, an Insurance Broker/Advisor is chosen by you, the buyer, so they will always represent you and not any of the company policies they present to you. An Insurance agent works for the company, while a broker works independently.

Leave a Comment