Finding the Best Home Insurance in Fort Myers, FL

Purchasing home insurance is crucial for protecting your most valuable asset – your home. Fort Myers, Florida homeowners need policies that properly cover hurricane risks, flooding, theft and liability. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know to find the ideal home insurance policy in the Fort Myers area.

Overview of Home Insurance in Fort Myers, FL

Home insurance, also called homeowners insurance, provides financial protection for your dwelling, belongings and liability risks. Here’s what to know about home insurance in Fort Myers:

  • Protects dwelling – Covers damage to the physical structure of your home and attached structures.

  • Covers possessions – Replaces personal belongings like furniture, clothes and electronics if damaged or stolen.

  • Provides liability coverage – Pays for injuries or property damage to others you are legally responsible for.

  • Common exclusions – Most policies don’t cover flood or earthquake damage by default.

  • Average cost – Expect to pay $3,000 – $4,000 per year for a typical Fort Myers home policy.

  • Key providers – Top insurers in Fort Myers include State Farm, Allstate, Progressive and USAA.

When choosing home insurance in the Fort Myers area, it’s important to understand major local risks like hurricanes, tropical storms and flooding. Purchasing adequate coverage limits for these perils is key.

Hurricane and Wind Damage Coverage

One of the biggest threats to Fort Myers homes is wind damage from tropical storms and hurricanes. Some key factors regarding windstorm coverage in Fort Myers:

  • Wind damage is covered under standard home insurance policies up to your dwelling limit.

  • For added protection, you can purchase separate windstorm coverage or increase dwelling limits.

  • Be prepared to pay a hurricane deductible (often 2-5% of the dwelling limit) if you file a wind damage claim.

  • Newer homes meeting strict Florida building codes tend to qualify for discounts on windstorm coverage.

  • Expect restrictions on purchasing new wind damage policies during hurricane season and storm watches.

When getting quotes, ask agents how much windstorm coverage is included and if you need extra protection. Carefully consider your hurricane deductible as well.

Flood Insurance in Fort Myers

Home insurance policies do not cover flood damage by default. To protect against floods, Fort Myers homeowners need separate insurance from the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private insurer. Key facts about flood insurance:

  • Any home can be insured by the NFIP, regardless of flood risk or past damage.

  • NFIP policies cover up to $250,000 for dwellings and $100,000 for personal property.

  • Private insurers like Lloyds of London offer higher flood insurance limits.

  • Costs average $700 per year but depend heavily on your property’s flood zone risk rating.

  • There is typically a 30-day waiting period before flood coverage goes into effect.

Flooding poses a major threat in low-lying Fort Myers neighborhoods. Don’t wait until a storm is on the horizon to purchase flood protection.

Home Insurance Costs in Fort Myers

The average Fort Myers homeowner pays around $3,000 per year for home insurance. However, rates can vary widely based on these factors:

  • Home value – The rebuild cost of your home is a primary cost driver. More expensive homes cost more to insure.

  • Location – Homes in high-risk flood zones or coastal areas tend to have pricier insurance. Inland areas often get lower rates.

  • Construction materials – Homes built with concrete/brick rather than wood frame tend to score discounts.

  • Deductible – Choosing a higher deductible (e.g. $2,500 instead of $500) reduces your premiums.

  • Claims history – Frequent past claims will increase your rates. A claims-free history helps lower costs.

  • Credit score – Insurers often check credit and offer discounts for better credit scores.

The best way to find affordable home insurance in Fort Myers is to compare rates from multiple top providers. This allows you to find the most savings for your particular home’s risks and attributes.

Top Home Insurance Companies in Fort Myers

Major insurers providing competitive rates and policies in the Fort Myers area include:

  • State Farm: Popular for bundling discounts, claims service and tech tools for managing your policy.

  • Allstate: Offers premium discounts for new homes, claim-free customers and bundling policies.

  • Progressive: Allows you to compare quotes and customize coverage online through their HomeQuote Explorer.

  • USAA: Specializes in coverage for military members and families. Consistently earns high marks for customer satisfaction.

  • Travelers: Provides robust coverage for older homes along with discounts for smart home tech and multi-policy bundling.

  • Nationwide: Policyholders can access emergency repairs 24/7 through Nationwide’s On Your Side program. Also noted for strong financial backing.

Partnering with highly-rated national carriers ensures financial stability and excellent claims service. But also consider local Fort Myers insurers and independent agents who know the area’s risks.

Tips for Finding the Best Home Insurance in Fort Myers

Follow these tips when shopping for Fort Myers home insurance:

  • Check flood zones – Knowing your flood risk helps determine if you need extra flood coverage.

  • Ask about discounts – Inquire about savings for security systems, new roofs, loyal customers and more.

  • Raise deductibles – Accepting higher deductibles saves substantially on premiums.

  • Compare quotes – Get quotes from at least three top-rated insurers to find the best rate.

  • Review exclusions – Ensure you understand and are comfortable with what is not covered by the policy.

  • Consider an umbrella policy – This provides additional liability coverage beyond your home policy limits.

  • Inspect annually – Doing an annual home inspection helps make sure your dwelling coverage limits are adequate.

Finding the right home insurance does not have to be a hassle, especially if you use an independent insurance agent. Agents shop multiple providers for you and help determine optimal coverage. Protect your Fort Myers property and finances by securing a customized and competitively priced home insurance policy.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fort Myers Home Insurance

What is the average cost of home insurance in Fort Myers?

The average Fort Myers homeowner pays around $3,000 per year for home insurance. However, rates vary widely based on your home’s value, location, construction materials and other factors. Getting quotes from multiple insurers helps find the best rate.

Does home insurance cover hurricane damage in Fort Myers?

Yes, standard home insurance policies cover wind damage from tropical storms and hurricanes up to your dwelling coverage limit. You can add separate hurricane or windstorm coverage for additional protection. Keep in mind you will pay a hurricane deductible if filing a hurricane-related claim.

Does homeowners insurance cover sinks holes in Fort Myers?

Home insurance policies in Florida do not automatically cover sinkhole damage. However, insurers are required to offer sinkhole coverage either as an add-on or through the state-run Citizens Insurance. Make sure to get either sinkhole coverage or coverage through Citizens to protect against this risk.

Does my mortgage lender require home insurance in Fort Myers?

Most likely yes. The vast majority of mortgage lenders will require you to purchase a homeowners insurance policy and list them on the policy as an additional interest. The lender wants to ensure their collateral (the home) is properly insured for any covered damages or loss.

How much dwelling coverage do I need for my Fort Myers home?

Your dwelling coverage limit should equal the full cost needed to completely rebuild your home in the event of a total loss. Factors like labor, materials, permits and debris removal should be accounted for. An insurance agent can help you accurately calculate the rebuild cost and determine sufficient dwelling coverage.

How much liability insurance should I get with my Fort Myers home policy?

Experts typically recommend a minimum of $300,000 to $500,000 in liability coverage. However, purchasing additional coverage up to $1 million or more is wise to fully protect your assets. An umbrella insurance policy adds further liability coverage on top of your underlying home policy’s limit.

Protecting your home and assets requires finding the right Fort Myers home insurance policy at a competitive rate. Speak with a knowledgeable independent insurance agent who can explain all your coverage options and find you the ideal policy for your situation.

Florida Home Insurance 101 for Moving to Fort Myers Florida


How much is home insurance in Fort Myers?

Homeowners insurance in Fort Myers typically costs between $1,200 and $2,600 per year, based on our research. Those figures are based on quotes from several top providers we surveyed for $300,000 of dwelling coverage and $100,000 of liability coverage.

What is the average cost for homeowners insurance in Florida?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Florida is $2,359 per year for a $250,000 baseline dwelling coverage. As you increase your coverage, your premiums will increase. In Florida, the baseline dwelling coverage amount is $250,000, and these policies cost an average of $2,359 per year.

Why is it so hard to get homeowners insurance in Florida?

The litigation costs proved to be too much for local, residential-only insurers and prompted seven of them to become insolvent. For national insurers, the costs have translated to higher premiums or fewer policy offerings. Florida’s hurricane risk has also played a role, as extreme weather has in many other states.

What company insures the most homes in Florida?

Insurance Company
Policies in Force
Universal Property and Casualty Insurance Company
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
Security First Insurance Company
Federated National Insurance Company

Leave a Comment