While there’s a lot to like about FHA loans, they may not be right for everyone. Before you make a major financial commitment, it’s important to understand the pros and cons of FHA loans. Only then can you truly decide whether it’s right for you.
Buying a home is an exciting milestone in life. As a first-time homebuyer I explored different mortgage options to find the best fit for my financial situation. The FHA loan caught my attention because of its low down payment requirement and flexible credit standards. However as I researched further, I realized this type of loan also has some significant drawbacks.
In this article, I’ll share the key disadvantages of an FHA loan based on my personal experience and research My goal is to provide an honest, balanced perspective to help other first-time homebuyers make an informed decision
What is an FHA Loan?
First, let’s quickly recap what an FHA loan is. The Federal Housing Administration (FHA) is a government agency that insures mortgages issued by FHA-approved lenders. The purpose of FHA loans is to make homeownership more accessible by offering low down payments and flexible underwriting.
Some key features of FHA loans:
- Down payments as low as 3.5% for borrowers with credit scores of 580 or higher
- More lenient debt-to-income ratio requirements
- Available to first-time homebuyers and buyers with lower credit scores
So in many ways, FHA loans can be a great option for buyers who may not qualify for conventional mortgages. However, there are also some significant drawbacks to weigh.
The Disadvantages of an FHA Loan
Based on my research from reputable sites like ConsumerAffairs and Rocket Mortgage, here are the key downsides I found about FHA loans:
1. Mortgage Insurance Premiums
One major disadvantage of FHA loans is that you have to pay mortgage insurance premiums (MIPs) for the life of the loan.
There are two types of MIPs on an FHA loan:
- Upfront MIP – 1.75% of the loan amount paid at closing
- Annual MIP – 0.45% to 1.05% of the loan amount paid monthly
So this adds a significant extra cost compared to conventional loans where you can drop mortgage insurance once you reach 20% equity.
Over a 30-year loan term, the annual MIP on an FHA loan can amount to over $30,000 in additional costs. That’s money doesn’t build any equity and could have gone toward paying off the principal.
2. Loan Limits
FHA loan limits are capped depending on your geographic location:
- Low-cost areas: $498,257
- High-cost areas: $1,149,825
If you need to borrow above these limits, an FHA loan won’t be an option. You’d have to look at a jumbo loan with likely higher rates and stricter requirements.
So in high cost-of-living areas, the FHA loan limits may be too low for many buyers. Conventional loans often have higher limits.
3. Strict Underwriting
The FHA has stringent underwriting standards for approving borrowers and properties:
- Minimum credit score requirements
- Careful scrutiny of your debt-to-income ratio
- Mandatory appraisal of the property
This underwriting can be more rigorous than conventional loans. I’ve read many accounts of buyers struggling to get property approvals due to minor repairs needed.
The result can be a longer, more frustrating mortgage process with an FHA loan. If you need to close quickly, conventional loans may be faster.
4. Lower Loan Amounts
Since FHA loans require lower down payments, they also cap the actual loan amount you can borrow. The reason is higher risk of default with smaller down payments.
For example, with a 3.5% down FHA loan, the maximum you can borrow is about 4.5 times your gross annual income. On a conventional loan with 20% down, you may be approved for 5 times income or higher.
So if you have limited savings but higher income, an FHA loan may prevent you from buying as much house as you can afford.
5. Refinancing Limitations
Once you have an FHA loan, refinancing into a conventional loan in the future involves additional costs and headaches.
To refinance into a non-FHA loan, you’ll need enough equity to eliminate the mortgage insurance. And there may be state and federal recapture taxes if you refi before 5 years.
These extra hurdles mean you could get “stuck” with an FHA loan longer than you may have planned. It’s smart to consider your long-term plans when getting an FHA mortgage.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
The downsides above paint a cautionary picture of FHA loans. But remember, they can still be the right choice depending on your financials and goals.
Here’s a quick recap of the key pros of FHA loans:
- Low down payments of just 3.5%
- More flexible credit score and debt ratio requirements
- Lower interest rates than subprime mortgages
- Several specialized loan programs
As a first-time buyer, I ultimately chose a conventional loan because I qualified and wanted to avoid FHA mortgage insurance. But many others in my situation have been grateful for the opportunity FHA loans provided them.
Do your homework and evaluate both the advantages and disadvantages before making a decision. Be sure to get rate quotes from multiple lenders as well. This will help ensure you find the most affordable home loan for your situation.
Alternatives to an FHA Loan
If you decide an FHA loan isn’t the right fit, here are a few alternatives worth considering:
Conventional 97 Loan – Requires just 3% down and avoids mortgage insurance.
VA Loan – For veterans and service members; no down payment needed.
USDA Loan – For low- to moderate-income buyers in rural areas; no down payment.
Down payment assistance programs – May provide grants, low interest loans, or forgivable loans to assist with down payment and closing costs.
Low down payment conventional loan – May require 5-10% down but have lower mortgage insurance than an FHA loan.
Piggyback loan – Combines a first and second mortgage, helping you avoid costly mortgage insurance.
Tips for First-Time Homebuyers
As a first-time buyer navigating all the mortgage options, I learned some key lessons that may help others in the same boat:
-
Shop around – Compare quotes from multiple lenders to find the best rates and loan programs. Leverage online tools to easily compare quotes.
-
Expand your options – Look beyond FHA and conventional loans. Consider all programs like VA, USDA, and down payment assistance.
-
Get pre-approved – Being pre-approved makes your offer stronger. But don’t just take the first pre-approval; shop around with multiple lenders first.
-
Buy below your means – Opt for lower-priced homes and smaller loans to reduce risk. Consider homes well below the maximum you’re approved for.
-
Prioritize 20% down – Saving up this down payment amount helps you avoid costly mortgage insurance and get better loan terms. But don’t wait forever; buying earlier can also make sense.
-
Improve your credit – Work on increasing your credit score and reducing debts. This opens up better mortgage rates and programs.
The Bottom Line
FHA loans provide a valuable option for qualifying buyers who may struggle to get approved for conventional mortgages. However, the trade-offs of higher costs, stringent requirements, and limits on refinancing need to be carefully weighed. Fortunately, buyers have many different loan programs and creative financing alternatives to consider.
As you navigate the mortgage process, be sure to educate yourself on all the pros, cons, and trade-offs of each option for your specific situation. With the right information and preparation, you can find the optimal home loan to make your dream of owning a home come true.
Advantages and Disadvantages of FHA Loans
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low Down Payment | Loan Limits |
| Low Credit Score Requirements | Higher Mortgage Insurance |
| No Income Limit | Strict Property Standards |
| Multiple Housing Options | Occupancy Requirements |
| Low PMI | Continuing Mortgage Insurance |
Lower Credit Score Requirements
Many people with bumps in their credit history worry that they wont be able to qualify for a home loan. Luckily, FHA loans are available to borrowers with less-than-ideal credit.
Most lenders will write FHA-backed loans for borrowers with credit scores of 580 or higher. If you’re in the 500-579 range, don’t despair. You can also qualify for an FHA loan, but you may need to come up with a 10% down payment instead of the standard 3.5%.
Note: Paddio currently looks for credit scores of 620 and above.
FHA loans are also sometimes a good option for people who have recently gone through a foreclosure or bankruptcy. Depending on your circumstances, you may be able to qualify for an FHA loan within one to two years after the incident.
FHA loans don’t have any minimum or maximum income requirements. This is a unique benefit not found in many other mortgage products, aside from the USDA loan. This means that higher-income earners with credit problems can still qualify for FHA loans. Even if you make a substantial salary each year, you can still benefit from the lower down payment and relaxed approval requirements.
You can use an FHA loan to purchase multiple types of properties. This includes single-family homes, condominiums on permanent land, manufactured homes on permanent land and multifamily homes with up to four units – though you may have a hard time finding a lender willing to do a manufactured loan.
This gives you plenty of options and some room to get creative. For example, you could buy a multifamily home and use the rent you would charge on the other units to qualify for the loan, as long as you live there as well.
Note: Paddio does not offer FHA financing for manufactured homes
If you put less than a 20% down payment, most conventional loans require you to carry Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI). This insurance provides the lender protection in case you fail to repay your loan. The premiums for PMI are often much higher if you have bad credit. With an FHA loan, however, you’ll pay the same insurance premium regardless of your credit score. If you’re credit-challenged, this could save you a significant amount of money over the lifetime of your loan.
The Good and BAD of FHA Loans | NEW FHA Loan Requirements 2023
FAQ
Why do people not accept FHA loans?
Why are FHA closing costs so high?
Why are sellers against FHA?
Does a FHA loan affect your credit score?
On an FHA loan, your credit score does not vastly affect the rate you receive to the extent that it does for conventional loans. This is another large benefit of the FHA loan as it applies to credit scores. On an FHA loan, the seller concessions can go up to 6%.
What are the pros and cons of FHA loans?
FHA loans have both advantages and drawbacks.Let’s break them down: **Benefits of FHA Loans:** 1.**Low Down Payment:** You can access financing for your home with only **3.5% down** if you have a credit
Are FHA loans a good idea?
FHA loans often require lower down payments and credit scores than conventional loans. First-time homebuyers and those with lower credit scores may particularly benefit from FHA loans. FHA loan amounts are limited, and FHA mortgage insurance premiums add up over time. What is an FHA loan?
Are FHA loans good for low down payments?
Both FHA and conventional loans can offer low down payments, but FHA loans can be beneficial for borrowers who may have a lower credit score. The downside is that you won’t be able to eliminate private mortgage insurance with an FHA loan .