Can an Executor Decide Who Gets What? Understanding the Power and Limitations of an Executor in Estate Administration

When planning your estate, choosing the right executor for your will is crucial. This individual will be responsible for managing your assets and distributing them to your beneficiaries after your passing. While the executor holds significant power, it’s important to understand their limitations and whether they have the authority to deviate from your wishes.

Can an Executor of a Will Decide Who Gets What?

In most cases, no, an executor cannot decide who inherits your assets. Their primary duty is to faithfully execute your will, ensuring your wishes are followed to the letter. This means they must distribute your assets as you have specified in the document.

However, certain situations may provide some leeway for the executor:

  • Unclear Instructions: If your will lacks clear instructions regarding the distribution of specific assets, the executor may have some discretion in deciding how to handle them. For example, if you leave instructions for your company to be liquidated and divided among your family but don’t specify what happens to the remaining assets, the executor will need to make a decision based on your overall intent.

  • Contested Will: If someone challenges the validity of your will in court, the executor may need to defend its authenticity and argue for its enforcement. While they cannot alter the beneficiaries or distribution plan, they can play a crucial role in ensuring your wishes are upheld.

What Power Does an Executor of a Will Have?

While an executor cannot arbitrarily change who receives your assets, they hold significant authority in managing and distributing your estate. Here are some of their key powers:

  • Managing Assets: The executor takes control of your assets, including property and investments, until the beneficiaries reach the age specified in your will or trust. They are responsible for safeguarding these assets and ensuring their proper management.

  • Distributing Estate Assets: The executor oversees the distribution of your assets according to your will’s instructions. This includes handling bank accounts, real estate, and personal belongings, ensuring they reach the intended beneficiaries.

  • Selling Estate Property: If necessary, the executor can sell estate property, such as your house, through a probate sale. They are responsible for managing the sale process and ensuring the proceeds are distributed according to your will.

  • Paying Debts and Taxes: The executor is responsible for paying any outstanding debts and taxes associated with your estate before distributing assets to beneficiaries.

  • Supervising Beneficiaries: If a beneficiary is a minor or has special needs, the executor may be tasked with supervising their inheritance until they reach a certain age or fulfill specific conditions.

  • Validating the Will: In the event someone contests your will in court, the executor is responsible for defending its validity and ensuring its enforcement.

Can You Challenge the Power of an Executor of a Will?

In most instances, the executor’s decisions are final, as they are acting on your behalf and following your wishes as outlined in the will. However, if a beneficiary believes the executor is acting improperly or exceeding their authority, they have the right to challenge their actions in court. Additionally, if someone contests the validity of the will itself, the court will have the final say on its enforceability and the distribution of your assets.

What an Executor Cannot Do

While the executor holds significant power, there are limitations to their authority:

  • Changing Beneficiaries: The executor cannot change the names of beneficiaries or alter the distribution plan outlined in your will. They are bound to follow your instructions, even if they disagree with them.

  • Preventing Will Contests: If a beneficiary believes the will is invalid or was signed under false pretenses, they have the right to contest it in court. The executor cannot prevent them from doing so.

  • Signing a Will for the Deceased: An executor cannot sign a will on behalf of the deceased. If you die without signing your will, it will be considered invalid and your assets will be distributed according to intestacy laws.

  • Distributing Assets Before Death: The executor cannot begin distributing your assets until after your passing. They must wait until your death is legally confirmed and the probate process is completed.

Can an Executor Decide Who Gets What If Someone Contests the Will?

If a beneficiary contests your will, the executor cannot prevent them from doing so. Their role is to defend the validity of the will and ensure your wishes are upheld. However, the court will ultimately decide whether the will is valid and how your assets should be distributed.

While an executor cannot arbitrarily decide who inherits your assets, they hold significant power in managing and distributing your estate. They are responsible for faithfully executing your will and ensuring your wishes are followed. However, it’s essential to understand the limitations of their authority and their inability to alter the distribution plan you have outlined. By carefully choosing an executor you trust and creating a clear and comprehensive will, you can ensure your wishes are respected and your assets are distributed according to your intentions.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. What happens if the executor does not follow the will?

If an executor fails to fulfill their duties or violates the terms of the will, they can be held liable for breach of fiduciary duty. This could result in legal action and potential financial consequences.

2. Can an executor be removed?

Yes, an executor can be removed by the court for various reasons, including incompetence, misconduct, or failure to perform their duties.

3. What are the qualifications for being an executor?

There are no specific legal qualifications for being an executor. However, it is generally recommended to choose someone who is trustworthy, organized, and has experience managing financial matters.

4. How long does the executor’s job last?

The executor’s job typically lasts until the estate is fully administered and all assets have been distributed to the beneficiaries. This process can take several months or even years, depending on the complexity of the estate.

5. How much does an executor get paid?

In most cases, executors are entitled to compensation for their time and services. The amount of compensation is typically determined by the court or negotiated with the beneficiaries.

6. What happens if I die without a will?

If you die without a will, your assets will be distributed according to the laws of intestacy in your state. This means your assets will be divided among your closest relatives, such as your spouse, children, or parents.

Additional Resources:


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult with an attorney to discuss your specific circumstances and legal options.

Can An Executor Of A Will Decide Who Gets What?

In most cases, no, an executor of a will can’t decide who gets what. It is their duty to distribute your belongings in accordance with the wishes you specify in your will. However, the executor may make these choices if the Will’s author did not provide clear guidance.

For example, in the event that a family member made a Will directing that their business be liquidated and divided among his relatives but leaving open what should happen to the remaining assets, the executor would have the authority to determine what should happen to the remaining property.

What Power Does An Executor Of A Will Have?

Selecting an executor for your Last Will and Testament is one of the most crucial and initial steps you should take when you start estate planning.

After your death, the executor will have a fiduciary duty to organize and oversee your estate. Additionally, they are in charge of allocating your assets to your beneficiaries. When you pass away, your executor will take over and carry out your final wishes in a more straightforward manner. But can an executor decide who gets what, you might be wondering?

can an executor of a will decide who gets what

Can an executor decide who gets what from a will? Oregon Attorney

Leave a Comment