Why Day Trading is Difficult and Not for Most People

Editorial Note Reviewed: Forbes Advisor partner links provide a commission to us. Commissions do not affect our editors opinions or evaluations.

Professional investors who trade stocks and other assets for a living are known as day traders. They hope to benefit from the minute-by-minute, hour-by-hour volatility of the stock market because they have a strong sense of discipline and a thorough understanding of market trends.

The emergence of inexpensive online brokerage platforms has made day trading tools widely available to all. Regular people can use and benefit from the same fast-paced strategies that were previously only available to Wall Street professionals if they are patient and focused.

Day trading, the practice of buying and selling financial instruments within the same trading day is often romanticized as a quick and easy way to make money. However, the reality is far from this perception. Day trading is a challenging endeavor that requires a deep understanding of the markets, a robust trading strategy significant time commitment, and the ability to manage emotions effectively.

Low Success Rate:

The success rate for day traders is notoriously low. Studies have shown that the majority of day traders lose money, with some estimates suggesting that only 10% are consistently profitable. This low success rate is attributed to several factors, including:

  • Lack of a Robust Strategy: Many day traders enter the market without a well-defined trading strategy, relying on intuition or emotional impulses. This lack of a structured approach leads to inconsistent trading decisions and ultimately, losses.
  • Insufficient Practice: Day trading requires extensive practice and experience to develop the necessary skills and discipline. However, many aspiring day traders underestimate the learning curve and attempt to trade with limited experience, leading to costly mistakes.
  • Market Volatility: The market is inherently unpredictable, and day traders must be able to navigate its constant fluctuations. Understanding the factors that influence market movements and developing the ability to adapt to changing conditions are crucial for success.
  • Emotional Control: Day trading is a highly emotional activity, and traders must be able to control their emotions to avoid making impulsive decisions. Fear and greed can lead to overtrading, holding onto losing positions, or selling winning positions too early, all of which can significantly impact profitability.

Challenges and Requirements:

In addition to the low success rate day trading presents several challenges that make it unsuitable for most people. These challenges include:

  • Time Commitment: Day trading requires significant time commitment, as traders need to monitor the markets throughout the trading day and execute trades in a timely manner. This can be difficult for individuals who have full-time jobs or other commitments.
  • Capital Requirements: While day trading can be done with a relatively small amount of capital, consistently generating profits requires a larger account size. This is because day trading involves frequent trading, and each trade incurs transaction costs.
  • Psychological Demands: Day trading can be emotionally draining, as traders are constantly exposed to the risk of losing money. This can lead to stress, anxiety, and even depression.

Alternatives to Day Trading:

For individuals who are interested in the financial markets but do not have the time, capital, or emotional fortitude for day trading, there are several alternative investment options available. These include:

  • Swing Trading: Swing trading involves holding positions for a longer period, typically from a few days to a few weeks. This allows traders to take advantage of larger market movements without the need to constantly monitor the markets.
  • Investing: Investing involves buying and holding financial instruments for an extended period, typically years or even decades. This is a more passive approach to investing that requires less time and effort than day trading.
  • Mutual Funds and ETFs: Mutual funds and ETFs are investment vehicles that pool money from multiple investors to purchase a diversified portfolio of assets. This allows investors to gain exposure to a variety of markets without the need to select individual stocks or other assets.

Day trading is a challenging endeavor that requires a deep understanding of the markets, a robust trading strategy, significant time commitment, and the ability to manage emotions effectively. Due to the low success rate and the demanding nature of day trading, it is not suitable for most people. Individuals who are interested in the financial markets but do not have the time, capital, or emotional fortitude for day trading should consider alternative investment options such as swing trading, investing, or mutual funds and ETFs.

What Is Day Trading?

Throughout the trading day, day traders frequently purchase and sell securities. In order to profit from intraday price fluctuations in assets such as stocks, bonds, commodities, and exchange-traded funds, day traders try to predict them.

Day trading is a short-term investing strategy, as the name would imply. The objective is to hold no securities overnight and to exit all of your trades by the end of the day.

Compare this strategy with long-term investing, in which you purchase a stock and hold it for several months or even years. Day traders aim to outpace the market and make rapid profits rather than waiting for time and compound interest to do the heavy lifting for them.

Even though day trading can appear thrilling and profitable, it is essentially gambling, with all of the risks and rewards associated with betting on any other sport. To get it right, you need a lot of practice and a high tolerance for risk.

6 Common Day Trading Strategies

You employ a strategy when day trading to find profitable investments. Some of the popular strategies used include the following.

In order to capitalize on market volatility before and after significant events, such as the release of the most recent jobs report or a Federal Reserve interest rate change, day traders closely monitor the news.

They look for assets that haven’t fully repriced in response to a breaking news event or try to forecast which way asset prices will move in response to significant news events.

When traders monitor the news flow for particular asset classes or individual stocks, this strategy is also effective. Trading a publicly traded company both before and after its quarterly earnings report is a typical strategy.

The goal of range trading is to find assets that frequently trade within a certain price range. When the investment’s market price is approaching the low end of the range, the trader wants to buy it, and when it approaches the high end of the range, they want to sell it.

Range trading involves exact timing, and if orders are not executed correctly, there could be large losses. Unexpected news or market events have the potential to disrupt price ranges, resulting in sudden and unfavorable price changes.

A quicker version of range trading, known as scalping, aims to buy and sell an investment at slight price fluctuations. A day trader who uses scalping may buy and sell hundreds of times a day for a single investment in an effort to make a tiny profit on each tiny movement. Scalpers follow short-term price charts trying to find these trends.

General price trends always apply to stocks and other investments. If a stock experiences a loss one day, it may continue to lose money as other investors sell their shares. In the meantime, a rising stock price could continue to rise as more investors join the trend.

Using the idea that previous price movements may be a good indicator of future trends, momentum investors attempt to profit from these price trends. Technical indicators and chart patterns are frequently used by momentum traders to determine when to enter and exit a trade.

In fading, a day trader follows a contrarian mindset. The trader sells assets that have increased in value or purchases assets that have been heavily liquidated. When a trader employs a fading strategy, they anticipate that prices will move too far in either direction due to the herd mentality.

Making money when markets overreact to news or events is the aim. Traders assume that prices eventually revert to the mean. However, fading can be a risky strategy because it deviates from the prevailing trend and could lead to losses if the market doesn’t immediately reach equilibrium levels.

Day traders often use leverage for their investments. This means trading with borrowed money, using margin. If your trades are successful, margin trading offers the potential for much larger gains, but it also has a much faster loss rate. Your broker also charges interest on margin loans.

Why is Being a Day Trader So Hard? (Stock Market 101)

FAQ

Why do 90% of day traders fail?

Most new traders lose because they can’t control the actions their emotions cause them to make. Another common mistake that traders make is a lack of risk management. Trading involves risk, and it’s essential to have a plan in place for how you will manage that risk.

Why do so many fail at day trading?

Not having and not following a trading plan is a big reason most traders fail. People without a plan are making an assumption that they are smarter than people who do this for a living, and therefore they don’t need to prepare, plan, or practice.

Is day trading actually profitable?

Day trading is a strategy in which investors buy and sell stocks the same day. It is rarely successful, with an estimated 95% loss percentage. Even if you do see a gain, it must be enough to offset fees and taxes, as well.

What is the hardest part of day trading?

The most challenging aspect of trading is gaining the qualitative skills. Those that come from experience or time spent in the markets. Being realistic and realising that you are probably just an average trader and that’s okay. It’s about learning how to keep going even when your account experiences a few losses.

Why is day trading so difficult?

Most day traders don’t see their efforts result in enough profits to pay themselves any type of income for many months. Numerous issues and situations contribute to making the market difficult to gauge and navigate. Taking the time to learn and understand what triggers shifts in trading activity can better prepare you to respond to those changes.

Is day trading worth it?

Day trading is not worth it for the vast majority of day traders. Anecdotally, it’s been widely estimated that 95% of day traders ultimately lose money, and it’s been empirically demonstrated that about the same percentage of unprofitable day traders continue despite losing money.

Do day trades make a lot of money?

Day trades usually generate quite little profit on every trade, which means that cutting expenses related to the execution of the trading strategy is crucial! If you’re interested in learning more about algorithmic trading and its benefits, be sure to check out our complete guide to algorithmic trading!

What are the risks of day trading?

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) highlights some of the risks of day trading, which are summarized below: Be prepared to suffer severe financial losses: Day traders typically suffer severe financial losses in their first months of trading, and many never make a profit.

Leave a Comment