Student loans can feel like a huge roadblock when trying to get approved for a mortgage. With over 43 million Americans carrying student loan debt totaling $1.7 trillion, many potential homebuyers have found their dreams of owning a home stalled due to the impact of student loans on their debt-to-income ratio.
Being denied a mortgage solely because of student loans can be incredibly frustrating. However, there are steps you can take to improve your financial profile and chances of getting approved the next time around. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll look at:
- Why student loans often lead to mortgage denial
- Tips to overcome mortgage denial due to student loans
- Rebuilding your application and reapplying
Follow these practical strategies, and you’ll be well on your way to qualifying for the mortgage you need to buy your dream home.
Why Student Loans Often Lead to Mortgage Denial
Student loans affect your ability to qualify for a mortgage in a few key ways:
1. High Debt-to-Income (DTI) Ratio
Your DTI ratio compares your total monthly debt payments to your gross monthly income Most conventional mortgages require your DTI to be below 43% But the higher your student loan payments, the more difficult it is to keep your DTI low.
Lenders may calculate your student loan payment in different ways:
- Using your actual monthly payment if it’s above $0
- Taking 1% of your total student loan balance
- Using a fully amortized payment based on your loan terms
No matter how it’s calculated, high student loan debt tends to inflate your DTI, making it harder to qualify.
2. Low Residual Income
Residual income is the money left over after you pay all your monthly debts and expenses. Lenders want to see you have adequate residual income to cover unforeseen costs.
High student loan payments eat into your residual income, raising doubts about your financial stability.
3. Credit Score Impact
The higher your student loan debt, the more your credit score may suffer. Too many student loans could indicate overextension on credit and hurt your credit mix.
Late or missed payments on your student loans also cause direct damage to your credit score.
A low credit score due to student loans can lead to mortgage denial.
Tips to Overcome Mortgage Denial Due to Student Loans
If your mortgage application was rejected because of student loan debt, don’t panic. Here are some tips to improve your chances next time:
1. Review Your Loan Application Denial Letter
Federal law requires lenders to send you a written notice explaining exactly why you were denied a mortgage.
Review this letter closely to understand what factors related to your student loans need fixing. Are your monthly payments too high? Is your overall student loan balance excessive?
Identify the core issues so you can address them properly.
2. Lower Your DTI Ratio
To counteract the impact of your student loans, take steps to lower your DTI ratio:
-
Increase your income: Consider taking on a side gig or part-time job for extra earnings. Even an extra $200 or $300 a month can make a difference.
-
Pay down debts: Be aggressive about paying off credit cards and other debts to free up cash flow.
-
Refinance student loans: Student loan refinancing could potentially lower your monthly payments, reducing your DTI.
-
Change repayment plans: Adjusting your federal loan repayment plan may help as well.
-
Make extra payments: Making extra student loan payments above your minimum due will shrink your balance faster, reducing DTI over time.
-
Get a non-zero payment: If you’re on an income-driven plan with a $0 payment, ask your servicer to give you a non-zero payment amount for mortgage qualification purposes.
3. Improve Your Credit Score
While you work on lowering your DTI, also focus on boosting your credit score by:
- Never missing a payment on all debts
- Keeping credit card balances low
- Limiting new credit inquiries
- Correcting any errors on your credit report
Added points on your credit score will strengthen your mortgage application.
4. Explore Different Loan Types
Conventional loans have the strictest requirements. But government-backed loans like FHA, VA, and USDA loans offer more flexibility for applicants with student loan debt.
The guidelines are nuanced but can possibly help you qualify.
5. Find the Right Mortgage Lender
Not all lenders interpret student loan guidelines the same way. Some may be unwilling to work with you.
Shop around and talk to several mortgage lenders. Look for one who is up-to-date on the latest student loan debt policies and takes the time to understand your full financial picture. An experienced broker can be a big help.
6. Get Credit Counseling
Consult with a nonprofit credit counseling agency. They can review your entire financial situation and provide expert guidance on managing your student loans while improving your mortgage qualifications.
7. Build Your Application Slowly
Don’t try to rush the process. Take 6-12 months to implement changes to your financial profile before reapplying for a mortgage.
With a methodical, step-by-step approach, you can structure your finances to achieve mortgage approval despite student loans.
Rebuilding Your Application and Reapplying
Once you’ve made improvements after being denied a mortgage, it’s time to reapply. But first, take a few key steps:
-
Check your credit report: Verify all negative issues from your student loans have been corrected or removed.
-
Get prequalified: Talk to a lender to get prequalified and confirm you’re within range for approval before formally applying again.
-
Gather documentation: Have the necessary paperwork ready to verify income, employment, assets, and student loan details.
-
Consider timing: If you recently increased income or paid down debts substantially, wait at least 2-3 months for the changes to be reflected in your credit report and financial documents.
When reapplying, be prepared to explain to the lender specifically how you addressed the student loan issues that previously led to denial. Provide supporting documentation.
Demonstrate the positive trajectory of your finances and your ability to manage mortgage payments responsibly.
While preapproval isn’t guaranteed, this targeted preparation will help you finally overcome mortgage denial because of student loans.
Key Takeaways
-
High student loan debt is a common barrier to mortgage qualification due to its effects on DTI, credit score, and residual income.
-
Targeted strategies like refinancing loans, increasing income, and improving your credit can help overcome a mortgage denial attributed to student loans.
-
Take sufficient time to rebuild your financial profile, document your progress, and find the right supportive lender when reapplying.
-
With persistence and diligence, you can achieve your homeownership dreams despite student loans. Don’t get discouraged by initial denial.
Owning a home remains a worthy pursuit. Stay determined in the face of setbacks, and leverage the advice above to get mortgage approval, student loans and all.
Pay Off Other Debts If You Can
If you have other high-interest debts, like credit cards, try to pay them down. It’ll lower your DTI and free up room for those mortgage payments.
Do I have to pay off student loans before buying a house?
A common misunderstanding is that you have to completely get rid of your student loans before owning a home. However, what really matters is handling your debt wisely and making sure it fits with your overall financial situation.
Lenders will assess your ability to handle mortgage payments alongside your existing debt obligations. So, even if you haven’t paid off your student loans completely, you could still buy a house as long as you demonstrate financial responsibility and a manageable debt load. It’s all about finding the right balance between your student loans and your homeownership goals.
What Everyone’s Getting Wrong About Student Loans
FAQ
Can you get denied a home loan because of student loans?
Will student loans hurt my chances of getting a mortgage?
Can student loans prevent you from buying a house?
Can you buy a house with 200k student loan debt?
Why was my mortgage application denied?
The Equal Credit Opportunity Act says your lender has 60 days to give you a specific reason why your loan application was not accepted. Some of the most common reasons a mortgage application is denied, according to HMDA data, are: Credit history. High debt-to-income ratio. Insufficient down payment.
Can a mortgage be denied if you pay your bills late?
Your mortgage could also be denied due to a previous late payment. If you’ve ever made a late payment toward a debt, whether it be student loans or an auto loan, it’s likely that this infraction found its way onto your credit report. Your lender may be more hesitant to grant you a mortgage loan if you’ve previously paid bills late. 4.
Can you get a mortgage with student loan debt?
Student loan debt can make it harder — but not impossible — for you to get a mortgage. Lenders consider student loan debt as a part of your total debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, which is a vital indicator of whether you’ll be able to make your future mortgage payments. Here’s what to know about getting a mortgage with student loans.
Can I take a mortgage if I’ve been denied?
“There’s no obligation for a consumer to take a loan at any point.” There is no mandatory waiting period after you’ve been denied. However, because a mortgage application usually involves a credit check, which can lower your score, it might be a good idea to wait a bit so that it has time to smooth out. A co-signer might also help you qualify.