We are an independent, advertising-supported comparison service. Our objective is to empower you to make confident financial decisions by giving you access to interactive tools and financial calculators, publishing original and unbiased content, and allowing you to conduct free research and information comparisons.
Issuers that Bankrate has partnerships with include American Express, Bank of America, Capital One, Chase, Citi, and Discover, among others.
Choosing the right IRA can be daunting, but it’s crucial for maximizing your retirement savings potential. This guide delves into the best IRA accounts available in 2024 helping you find the perfect fit for your needs and goals.
Understanding Your IRA Options: Traditional vs. Roth
Before diving into specific providers, let’s clarify the two main IRA types:
Traditional IRA:
- Contributions are pre-tax, reducing your current taxable income.
- Investments grow tax-deferred, meaning you pay taxes only when withdrawing funds in retirement.
- Ideal for those in higher tax brackets now and expecting lower ones in retirement.
Roth IRA:
- Contributions are made with after-tax dollars, offering no immediate tax deduction.
- Investments grow tax-free, and qualified withdrawals in retirement are also tax-free.
- Beneficial for those in lower tax brackets now and anticipating higher ones in retirement.
Top IRA Providers in 2024: A Detailed Overview
1. Charles Schwab:
- Renowned for investor-friendliness and a vast array of investment options, including individual stocks, bonds, funds, and CDs.
- Offers thousands of commission-free mutual funds and a user-friendly trading platform for active investors.
- Excellent choice for both active and passive investors seeking a comprehensive IRA solution.
2. Wealthfront:
- A leading robo-advisor that constructs personalized retirement portfolios based on your risk tolerance and time horizon.
- Features automatic rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting, ensuring your portfolio stays on track.
- Offers a sophisticated goal-based planner and a fully featured cash management account.
- Ideal for investors seeking a hands-off, professionally managed IRA at a low cost.
3. Fidelity Investments:
- A top-rated brokerage with exceptional customer service, robust trading platforms, and a wide selection of investments.
- Offers four commission-free mutual funds and thousands more with no transaction fees.
- Caters to both active traders and passive investors with its diverse investment options and user-friendly platforms.
4. Vanguard:
- Renowned for its low-cost mutual funds, making it a perfect choice for passive investors.
- Offers over 3,000 mutual funds with no transaction fees, allowing you to build a diversified portfolio without incurring additional costs.
- Also provides commission-free trading for stocks and ETFs, catering to a wider range of investor preferences.
5. Betterment:
- A robo-advisor that manages your IRA for a low, flat fee of 0.25%.
- Offers automatic rebalancing, tax-loss harvesting, and access to human advisors for a higher fee.
- Ideal for investors seeking a hassle-free, professionally managed IRA with the option for personalized guidance.
6. Interactive Brokers:
- A brokerage offering access to global markets, catering to experienced investors and active traders.
- Provides two platforms: Pro for advanced traders and Lite for commission-free stock and ETF trades.
- Suitable for investors seeking a diverse range of investment options and advanced trading tools.
7. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios:
- A robo-advisor from Charles Schwab that manages your IRA with a personalized portfolio and low-cost ETFs.
- Offers a premium tier with access to human advisors for a flat monthly fee.
- Ideal for investors seeking a combination of robo-advisor management and human guidance.
8. Merrill Edge:
- A brokerage providing access to stock research, strong customer service, and in-person assistance through Bank of America branches.
- Offers over 6,000 commission-free mutual funds and caters to both active and passive investors.
- Perfect for investors seeking a comprehensive brokerage experience with personalized support.
9. Fundrise:
- A unique platform that allows you to invest in real estate through your IRA.
- Offers REITs, providing access to a diversified real estate portfolio and potential for regular income.
- May not be suitable for all investors due to potential lock-up periods.
10. E-Trade:
- A popular brokerage offering commission-free trading for stocks, ETFs, and options.
- Provides access to thousands of commission-free mutual funds and robust research tools.
- Caters to both active traders and passive investors with its diverse investment options and user-friendly platform.
11. Firstrade:
- A brokerage offering commission-free trading for stocks, ETFs, and options.
- Provides access to thousands of no-transaction-fee mutual funds and various IRA account types.
- Ideal for active traders and investors seeking a wide range of investment options at no additional cost.
12. Fidelity Go:
- A robo-advisor from Fidelity with low fees and personalized portfolios built using Fidelity’s zero-expense-ratio funds.
- Provides access to Fidelity’s extensive educational resources and 24/7 customer service.
- Suitable for investors seeking a low-cost, professionally managed IRA with access to Fidelity’s benefits.
Choosing the Right IRA for You: Key Considerations
While these providers offer excellent IRA options, the best choice for you depends on your individual circumstances and preferences. Consider the following factors:
- Investment style: Active or passive, hands-on or hands-off?
- Risk tolerance: How comfortable are you with market fluctuations?
- Investment goals: What are you aiming to achieve with your IRA?
- Fees: What are the associated management fees, transaction costs, and minimum investment requirements?
- Customer service: What level of support do you require?
- Additional features: Do you need access to research tools, educational resources, or human advisors?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
1. What is the best IRA for beginners?
For beginners, robo-advisors like Wealthfront, Betterment, or Fidelity Go can be excellent choices. They provide automated portfolio management, making it easy to get started.
2. What is the best IRA for active traders?
Active traders might prefer brokers like Interactive Brokers, E-Trade, or Firstrade, which offer commission-free trading and advanced platforms.
3. What is the best IRA for hands-off investors?
Passive investors can benefit from robo-advisors like Wealthfront, Betterment, or Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, which manage your portfolio automatically.
4. Can I have multiple IRAs?
Yes, you can have multiple IRAs, but the total contributions across all your IRAs cannot exceed the annual contribution limit.
5. What happens to my IRA when I retire?
At retirement, you can start withdrawing funds from your IRA. However, you will need to pay taxes on any pre-tax contributions and earnings in a traditional IRA. In a Roth IRA, qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
Choosing the right IRA is a crucial step towards securing your financial future. By carefully considering your needs and goals, and exploring the options provided by top IRA providers, you can find the perfect fit for your retirement savings journey.
Best IRA accounts to open in April 2024
When creating your IRA, these are some of the top brokers or robo-advisors to choose from.
Charles Schwab has a longstanding reputation for being investor-friendly and performs all essential brokerage tasks well. Schwab can help you with stocks, bonds, funds, and even certificates of deposit (CDs) in your IRA. Indeed, there are thousands of mutual funds available from Schwab with no transaction fees. Additionally, the broker consistently ranks among the best in the business thanks to commission-free trades and prompt customer service. Of course, you can use thinkorswim, the premier trading platform from Schwab, to increase your level of activity and place trades.
Ideal for: Investors seeking to manage their IRA either actively or passively
One of the best robo-advisors is Wealthfront, which can build your retirement portfolio according to your risk tolerance and the precise timing of your financial needs. To ensure that your allocations remain on target, Wealthfront automatically rebalances your portfolio. Additionally, even without your IRA here, you have access to a sophisticated goal-based planner and a feature-rich cash management account. The management fee is a reasonable 0. As with any other investment, you will pay for the ETFs held in your portfolio at a rate of twenty-five percent annually, or $25 for every $10,000 invested.
Ideal for: Investors seeking affordable, professionally managed portfolios
One of the best brokers overall, Fidelity excels in everything they do, from providing strong trading platforms for active traders to offering a wide selection of investments (thousands of mutual funds available without a transaction fee) and a policy of not charging you for every little thing. Additionally, it doesn’t hurt that the broker provides four mutual funds that are excellent choices for IRA investors because they have no management fees. High quality work is done by Fidelity, so you won’t be let down.
Ideal for: Investors seeking to engage in active trading or passive investing
Even though you could purchase its mutual funds at a different broker, Vanguard is a fantastic option for affordable mutual funds. Even though Vanguard has eliminated online trading commissions for stocks and ETFs to zero, like the majority of large brokers, it is still a fantastic choice for passive investors. Additionally, Vanguard provides more than 3,000 mutual funds fee-free. Therefore, you won’t have any trouble locating the few funds you need if those are more your style.
Ideal for: Investors seeking passive IRA management, particularly with Vanguard funds
Betterment is probably a good choice if you’re okay with having someone else manage your retirement account. For one low, flat fee of 0. 25 percent, all you have to do is add money, and this robo-advisor will handle your portfolio from beginning to end. For no additional cost, you’ll receive beneficial features like automated rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting. Additionally, if you add $100,000 or more to the account and pay a slightly higher fee, you will have access to human advisors for all of your in-depth inquiries.
Perfect for: Investors who wish to have their IRA managed by a robo-advisor or who occasionally need access to a human planner
If you’re looking for a brokerage that can help you “go anywhere,” Interactive Brokers is the place to go. They offer you plenty of access to global markets. Although you don’t have to be an active trader to open an IRA with Interactive Brokers, the company has a long history of serving serious investors. Choose the Pro platform of the brokerage, which is renowned for its excellent execution, or use the Lite platform, which offers free trades. In either case, you’ll be making an investment with one of the safest companies in the world.
Ideal for: Investors who wish to access a variety of markets and engage in active trading
With Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, a robo-advisor that manages your IRA with a customized portfolio, Schwab lends its reputation as an investor-friendly firm. There is no management fee at Schwab, and its inexpensive ETFs and highly regarded 24/7 customer service are all things you’ll appreciate. You can upgrade to the premium tier, which costs a fixed $30 per month (after a $300 one-time setup fee), if you want access to financial advisors. In either scenario, you will need to bring some cash to the robo-advisor: $5,000 for the basic service and $25,000 for the premium.
Ideal for: Those seeking affordable professional management with the possibility of unrestricted access to human advisors
You will gain from Merrill Edge’s extensive offerings, access to stock research, and first-rate customer support as a client. Additionally, Merrill is an excellent option if you anticipate requiring in-person support because parent company Bank of America provides Merrill representatives at over 2,000 branches, which is a significant competitive advantage. Another benefit is that having all of your financial affairs in one location is simply easier if you are already a customer of the bank.
Ideal for: Investors who prefer to trade either actively or passively, or who might require the assistance of a human planner
Fundrise may be a good option for you if you want to use your IRA for something unconventional. Fundrise allows you to invest in real estate with your IRA. Since real estate tends to generate cash that would otherwise be taxable, real estate may be a great fit for an IRA. Investing with Fundrise gives you access to reputable real estate investment trusts (REITs), which are well-known for distributing dividends to investors and providing a diversified real estate portfolio. Fundrise might not be for everyone because you might have to lock in your money for years. But Fundrise might be a compelling choice for investors seeking for an alternative investment, like real estate.
Ideal for: Those looking to explore and make real estate investments
In addition to providing commission-free stock and ETF trading, E-Trade is a great option for mutual funds, as it offers over 6,000 options without a transaction fee. This makes it comparable to other major brokers. Another all-in-one broker is E-Trade, which is excellent for both active traders (volume discounts on options, the Power E-Trade platform) and long-term, passive investors (third-party research).
Ideal for: Investors seeking to engage in either active or passive investing
Firstrade has a lot to offer investors who are saving for retirement, but it is also well-liked by traders due to its commission-free stock, ETF, and option trading. Firstrade allows you to open almost any kind of IRA account you desire, including SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, which aren’t offered by all brokers. Firstrade also offers thousands of mutual funds with no transaction fees. Additionally, there’s a good research offering with free Morningstar report access.
Ideal for: Investors seeking to engage in either active or passive investing
Another robo-advisor to think about is Fidelity Go, if you want to manage your portfolio more passively. For accounts under $25,000, there is no fee, or a fee of 0. 35 percent after that. You won’t have to worry about the additional fund fees that most robo-advisors charge because the portfolios are constructed using Fidelity funds, which do not impose expense ratios. Additionally, you will receive all of Fidelity’s perks, such as excellent learning materials and round-the-clock customer support.
Ideal for: Investors seeking a professionally managed, low-cost portfolio
The IRA: What you need to know
You can save for retirement and get a tax break this year with a traditional IRA. Also, until you remove the funds from the account at retirement, which is defined as age 59 1/2 or older, you will benefit from tax-deferred growth on your investments. Any contributions you make to the account will typically be tax-free, so it’s a good way to lower your current taxes.
It helps to think of an IRA as a regular account’s “wrapper” or “shield” that keeps it safe from the IRS. An IRA is provided by numerous financial institutions, such as banks, brokerages, insurance providers, and robo-advisors, and each one may let you make different types of investments.
Your final IRA earnings are determined by these types of investments. Investing in stocks, which have historically performed well, could yield higher returns over time than CDs and bonds. But there’s a trade-off to be aware of: safer assets typically fluctuate far less or, in certain situations (like CDs), are risk-free. Higher-performing investments, on the other hand, require you to take on more risk.
To ensure that you are making the most out of the plan and avoiding any potential pitfalls, you should read the entire information on the IRA. It’s easy to understand why it’s such a well-liked retirement vehicle.